Reading time: 11 minutes
Neither route wins every time. A mortgage broker can compare the lenders they are accredited with and must act in your best interests. A bank can only offer its own loans, but sometimes its offer, or a direct online lender's, is the best one on the table. Nothing guarantees a cheaper loan or an approval. The only fair test is to put real offers side by side.
Is it better to use a mortgage broker or go directly to a bank?
It depends on how many lenders you want compared, how complex your finances are and what the actual offers say. Brokers arrange most new home loans in Australia, but that does not prove a broker is better for you. This table sets the two routes side by side.
| Question | Mortgage broker | Bank (going direct) |
|---|---|---|
| Who they work for | They assist you with credit from the lenders they are accredited with. Lenders generally pay them. | Their employer, the lender. Staff sell the bank's own loans. |
| Legal duty | Best interests duty under the National Consumer Credit Protection Act since 1 January 2021, plus responsible lending rules. | Responsible lending rules apply to the lender. The broker best interests duty does not apply to staff selling their employer's own loans. |
| Lender choice | The lenders they are personally accredited with. Not every lender is available. | One lender. You can still collect offers from several banks yourself. |
| Cost to you | Lenders generally pay brokers. Some brokers also charge you a fee, which must be quoted in writing and accepted before they assist. | Loan fees and interest apply in every route. Check the Key Fact Sheet for the loan. |
| Who the route suits | Buyers who want several lenders compared, have a more complex income or deposit, or want someone to coordinate the process. | Buyers who already hold an offer worth testing, want a direct only product, or have a simple application. |
| Documents you get | Credit Guide early on, a fee quote if a fee applies, and a Credit Proposal when they assist. If the broker provided credit assistance, you can ask for a free copy of the written assessment for up to seven years from the date of the quote. | The Key Fact Sheet for the specific loan, the lender's offer and the loan contract. |
| Who decides if you are approved | The lender. The broker recommends and submits. | The lender. |
The sections below explain each row. For how brokers are paid, read how mortgage brokers get paid. For checking one before you sign, read how to choose a mortgage broker.
What is the difference between a mortgage broker and a bank lender?
A bank lender is the credit provider. It offers its own home loans and makes the final decision on your application. A mortgage broker is an intermediary. They help you compare loans from more than one lender, put the application together and submit it. The lender still decides.
| Mortgage broker | Bank lender | |
|---|---|---|
| Role | Intermediary giving credit assistance | Credit provider lending its own money |
| Products | Loans from the lenders they can access | Its own loans only |
| Decision maker | Does not approve loans | Makes the final assessment and approves or declines |
| What they assess | A preliminary assessment before they give credit assistance | A final assessment before it enters the loan |
The law draws this line in the definition of a mortgage broker. It covers a business that assists with credit involving more than one credit provider. A bank employee selling their own employer's loans does not fit that definition.
Does a bank have the same best interests duty as a broker?
No, not the same one. The best interests duty applies to mortgage brokers, in force since 1 January 2021. Bank staff selling their employer's own loans are not mortgage brokers. That does not make banks unregulated. Responsible lending rules apply to banks and brokers alike.
| Obligation | Mortgage broker | Bank staff selling the bank's loans |
|---|---|---|
| Best interests duty (sections 158LA and 158LE) | Yes | Not as a mortgage broker |
| Put your interests ahead of their own if there is a conflict (sections 158LB and 158LF) | Yes | Not as a mortgage broker |
| Make inquiries about your finances, requirements and objectives | Yes | Yes, as the credit provider |
| Take reasonable steps to verify your financial situation | Yes | Yes |
| Not suggest, assist with or enter into unsuitable credit | Yes | Yes |
A legal duty is a rule, not a guarantee that every adviser follows it. ASIC's recent review, covered further down, found weak spots in how some broker firms explain their recommendations.
Can a mortgage broker get a better interest rate than a bank?
Sometimes. A broker can compare lenders they have access to and ask a lender to reconsider. That can help, but it does not mean a broker beats every bank every time. The only way to know is to compare documented offers for your circumstances, not the best case rates in advertisements.
Ask for the same inputs on each offer: loan amount, deposit, term, rate type and the date of the quote. The worksheet later in this guide shows the fields to compare. A broker's recommendation and a bank's offer are only comparable if they use the same assumptions.
Can going directly to a lender be cheaper?
Yes, it can. Some lenders sell only to customers directly, and a broker cannot place a loan with them. Unloan, for example, says it offers home loans online and direct to the customer. If a direct offer beats what a broker finds, that is just a better offer.
Direct lenders can carry other limits. Unloan's FAQ says it does not take part in government grants or assistance schemes. If you plan to use a scheme, confirm in writing that the lender supports it before you compare rates. The check applies to a broker's shortlist too.
| Check | Broker accessible offer | Direct only offer |
|---|---|---|
| Is the lender on the broker's accredited list? | Ask the broker to confirm in writing | Not available through brokers |
| Does it support your scheme or grant? | Ask the lender | Ask the lender |
| Is there a Key Fact Sheet for your loan? | Ask for it | Ask for it |
| Who handles questions after settlement? | Ask the broker | The lender's own service channels |
Do mortgage brokers compare every lender?
No. A broker compares the lenders they are accredited with, and that is a subset of the market. ASIC expects a reasonably representative panel but sets no universal minimum number of lenders. Some lenders are not available through brokers at all.
| What you might be told | What it can mean | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| "We have access to many lenders" | That is the aggregator's panel, which can be wider than what this broker uses | Which lenders are you personally accredited with? |
| "We compared the market" | They compared lenders they can access | Which relevant lenders are not available through you? |
| A long lender list on a website | Headline numbers do not show where most loans are placed | Check the Credit Guide, which names the six credit providers the broker does the most business with |
| A white label loan under a familiar brand | The brand on the loan may differ from the company funding it. AFG, for example, describes a white label product funded by another company | Who sets the terms, assesses the application and services the loan? |
What are the disadvantages of using a mortgage broker?
Brokers have real limits. Coverage is incomplete, service varies between brokers, there is another person between you and the lender, and some brokers charge fees. Lender paid commission also creates a conflict that the law manages but does not remove.
| Drawback | Evidence | Question to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Some lenders are out of reach | Direct only lenders exist. Panels differ from broker to broker. | Which lenders can you not use for me? |
| Conflict of interest | Lenders generally pay brokers. The law adds a best interests duty and conflict priority rules for that reason. | Why this loan, and what cheaper options did you consider? |
| Recommendations that are not the cheapest | ASIC's October 2026 review found weak explanations in some firms (details below). | Can I have the reasons in writing? |
| Possible fees | Some brokers charge. Home Loan Experts, for example, publishes a $300 assessment fee that is refunded if you get a loan through it. | What could I pay, and when? Is it quoted in writing? |
| Another person in the chain | Questions pass through the broker to the lender and back. | Who is my contact, and how do I check my application status? |
| Service quality varies | A licence is not a quality ranking. | What do you promise after settlement, in writing? |
Fee rules and commission figures are in how mortgage brokers get paid. Checking credentials is in how to choose a mortgage broker.
When might going directly to a bank make sense?
Going direct can make sense when you already hold a competitive written offer, when a direct only lender suits you, or when your application is simple and you are comfortable doing the comparing. It is a legitimate choice, not a mistake.
| Situation | Why direct can fit | Evidence to hold |
|---|---|---|
| You have a competitive offer from your own bank | You can test it against others without a middle step | The written offer and its Key Fact Sheet |
| You want a lender that does not use brokers | Only direct application is possible | The lender's own loan documents, and confirmation it supports any scheme you plan to use |
| Your income and deposit are simple | There is less to structure or explain | Your own comparison of at least two lenders on the same inputs |
| You are comfortable with forms and follow up | You manage the lender relationship yourself | A checklist of documents the lender asks for |
You can still ask a broker to test your bank's offer afterwards. A second view costs you little if the broker does not charge a fee. Always confirm that in writing first.
When might a mortgage broker be useful for a first home buyer?
A broker can help when the process is new to you, when you want several lenders compared, or when something about your situation needs explaining to a lender. They cannot change the rules for a scheme or make a lender take part in one.
| Your need | What a broker can do | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Understanding your options | Explain loan types and compare the lenders they can access | Only lenders they are accredited with |
| Finding lenders that suit your income | Match your income type to lender policies | The lender still decides |
| Using a government scheme | Tell you which of their lenders take part | Assistance with a scheme is not eligibility. Lenders set participation. |
| Coordinating the process | Prepare and submit the application, chase documents, keep you updated | You still supply documents and sign |
Timing helps. Talking to a broker or a bank before you start inspecting properties gives you a clearer budget. Our borrowing power calculator gives a starting number, and our pre approval guide explains what comes next. Check your scheme options with the first home buyer eligibility checker.
Who handles the paperwork when I use a broker or a bank?
You supply the documents in either route. With a broker, they collect and check them, prepare the application and deal with the lender. With a bank, you deal with the lender yourself. Either way, expect to be asked for proof of income, savings, debts and spending.
| Task | Using a broker | Going direct |
|---|---|---|
| Gather payslips, statements and ID | You | You |
| Check your finances and needs | Broker makes inquiries and verifies | Lender makes inquiries and verifies |
| Compare loans | Broker, across their accredited lenders | You, across the lenders you contact |
| Complete and submit the application | Broker, with your signature | You |
| Answer lender questions | Usually through the broker, though the lender may contact you | You |
| Assess and approve | Lender | Lender |
A broker does not mean you avoid every form or every call from the lender. Ask who your day to day contact will be.
Can a broker guarantee my home loan will be approved?
No. A broker recommends a loan and submits the application. The lender assesses it and decides. Approval can come with conditions that are still outstanding. Read the approval documents to see what remains.
| Step | Who | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Comparison | Broker or you | A shortlist of loans that look suitable |
| 2. Application | Broker or you | The lender receives your documents |
| 3. Assessment | Lender | The lender verifies your finances and decides |
| 4. Outcome | Lender | Approval, approval with conditions, or decline |
If a broker says a loan is "as good as approved", ask what the lender has actually told them and request the lender's own written status.
How should I compare a bank offer with a broker's recommendation?
Compare the Key Fact Sheet for each specific loan, not the headline rate. Line up the rate, fees, repayments, loan term and features. A comparison rate includes the interest rate and most fees, but not every cost or condition. Use the same loan amount and term for each.
| Field | Bank offer | Broker recommendation | Direct online offer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Date of quote | |||
| Loan amount and term | |||
| Rate type (variable or fixed) | |||
| Interest rate and comparison rate | |||
| Upfront and ongoing fees | |||
| Repayment amount | |||
| Features you want (offset, redraw) | |||
| Conditions (for example scheme support) | |||
| Service after settlement |
Copy this table into a note and fill in each column. If a field is missing, write "not enough information to compare". Do not guess. A blank is a reason to ask, and it should not count as a win for either route.
Why might a broker recommend a loan that is not the cheapest?
A higher cost loan can be justified if it gives you something you need, such as a feature or a lender that accepts your income type. But there should be a clear reason tied to your situation, written down, not just a general statement.
ASIC looked at this in a review published on 13 October 2026. It examined 13 credit licensees across 8 aggregator groups. Seven of the eight groups reported that the cheapest loan was not recommended in more than 20% of cases between 1 April 2023 and 31 March 2025. ASIC reviewed 1,600 recommendations, picked because they involved a recommendation that was not the cheapest or a comparison of a single loan. It was not a random sample, so it does not give a national rate of poor recommendations. A recommendation that is not the cheapest is not automatically a breach.
| If the recommended loan costs more | What to ask for |
|---|---|
| Higher interest or fees | The cheaper options they considered and the cost difference |
| A feature you did not ask for | Why that feature suits you |
| A lender you have not heard of | Who the lender is and who funds the loan |
| A reason that sounds general | The reason in writing, tied to your goals |
How many Australian home loans are arranged through brokers?
Brokers arranged 81.6% of new residential lending in the June quarter 2026, according to research by Cotality commissioned by the MFAA, published on 3 September 2026. Popularity does not show that a broker is better for any one borrower.
| Period | Broker share of new residential lending |
|---|---|
| June quarter 2024 | 73.7% |
| June quarter 2025 | 77.6% |
| March quarter 2026 | 81.0% |
| June quarter 2026 | 81.6% |
A separate survey measures something different. The FBAA consumer survey (fieldwork 25 March to 17 April 2025, 1,342 usable responses) asked people who obtained a mortgage in the preceding 12 months which channel they used. The two sets of figures are not directly comparable, so we do not average them.
| Channel (FBAA survey, 2025) | Respondents who obtained a mortgage in the preceding 12 months |
|---|---|
| Mortgage broker | 67% |
| Lender online | 24% |
| Bank branch | 9% |
How can I find a broker to compare with my bank's offer?
Bring your bank's written offer to a broker and ask for a documented comparison on the same loan amount, term and rate type. NestPath can match you with a broker for that comparison.
Bring your bank's offer to a matched broker
NestPath's broker matching is free for you. If you go ahead with a matched broker, the broker pays NestPath a referral fee. Matching is a starting point, not a recommendation. Check any broker using how to choose a mortgage broker, ask for the documents listed above, and compare the result with your bank's offer.
This guide is general information, not personal advice.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to use a mortgage broker or go to the bank?
Neither wins every time. A broker can compare the lenders they are accredited with and must act in your best interests. A bank can only offer its own loans, but its offer, or a direct online lender's, is sometimes the best one available. Neither route guarantees a cheaper loan or an approval, so compare written offers for the same loan amount, term and rate type.
Does a bank have a best interests duty like a mortgage broker?
Not the broker version. The best interests duty has applied to mortgage brokers since 1 January 2021. Bank staff selling their employer's own loans are not mortgage brokers under the law. Banks are still bound by responsible lending rules, which require inquiries into your finances, reasonable verification and no unsuitable credit.
Can a mortgage broker get a better rate than a bank?
Sometimes, but not always. A broker can compare the lenders they can access and ask a lender to reconsider. That does not prove a broker beats every bank. The only reliable test is to compare documented offers, using the Key Fact Sheet for each loan, on the same loan amount, term and rate type.
What are the reasons not to use a mortgage broker?
Some lenders are not available through brokers, panels differ from broker to broker, and an extra person sits between you and the lender. Lenders generally pay brokers, which creates a conflict the law manages but does not remove. Some brokers also charge a fee, which must be quoted in writing and accepted first. ASIC's October 2026 review found weak explanations in some firms for loans that were not the cheapest.
When does it make sense to go directly to a bank?
Going direct can fit when you already hold a competitive written offer, when you want a lender that does not use brokers, or when your finances and deposit are simple and you are comfortable comparing lenders yourself. If you plan to use a government scheme, confirm in writing that the lender supports it first.
Do mortgage brokers compare every lender?
No. A broker compares the lenders they are personally accredited with. ASIC expects a reasonably representative panel but sets no minimum number of lenders. Some lenders sell only direct. Ask which relevant lenders are not available through the broker, and check the Credit Guide for the six lenders they do the most business with.
Can a mortgage broker guarantee my loan will be approved?
No. A broker recommends a loan and submits the application, but the lender assesses it and makes the decision. An approval can also come with conditions still to be met. Ask for the lender's own written status instead of relying on a verbal assurance.
How many home loans go through brokers in Australia?
Brokers arranged 81.6% of new residential lending in the June quarter 2026, according to research by Cotality commissioned by the MFAA and published on 3 September 2026. A separate FBAA survey of people who got a mortgage in the preceding 12 months found 67% used a broker. The two measures differ, and neither shows that a broker is better for any one borrower.
More answers: 50 first home buyer questions, answered with sources.
How we checked: every figure on this page was read on the official source pages listed below on 28 October 2026.
Sources
- ASIC Moneysmart, Using a mortgage broker, updated 13 October 2026.
- ASIC Moneysmart, Choosing a home loan, updated 16 September 2026.
- Federal Register of Legislation, National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009, compilation dated 30 June 2026.
- ASIC, Regulatory Guide 273 (RG 273), published 24 June 2020.
- ASIC, Responsible lending, no date shown on the page.
- ASIC, Responsible lending disclosure obligations: overview for credit licensees and representatives (INFO 146), no date shown on the page.
- ASIC, Report 840 (REP 840), published 13 October 2026.
- MFAA, Mortgage broker market share reaches record 81.6%, 3 September 2026.
- FBAA and Agile Market Intelligence, Consumer attitudes survey report, labelled 2025, no exact publication date shown.
- Unloan, FAQs (its own product facts only), no date shown on the page.
- AFG, AFG launches AFG Home Loans Bridge in partnership with Bridgit (its own product only), no date shown on the page.
- Home Loan Experts, Our fees (its own fees only), no date shown on the page.



