The best men's loafer for most people is the Rockport Classic Penny Loafer, because its listing gives it a leather outer material, truTECH heel cushioning and removable insoles, and its description pairs it with a suit for the office or khakis for dinner with friends. This page compares seven loafers and slip ons by what each listing states, plus its star rating and rating count, and nothing on it is a hands on test.
The Go Tour Suede Leather Casual Loafers come second, and the Crocs Santa Cruz Loafer and Merrell Jungle Moc come next, a casual slip on loafer and a moc slip on shoe. The Florsheim dress, Go Tour driving and FitVille wide fit loafers follow, each for its own style. Our women's loafers guide covers the women's range, while this page covers men's styles only.
| Pick | Style words in the listing | Upper as the listing gives it | Sizes the listing names |
| Rockport Classic Penny Loafer | Penny loafer, dress shoe | Leather | US 6.5 to 16, wide sizes named |
| Go Tour Suede Leather Casual Loafers | Casual loafer, classic loafer | Suede leather (facts block); one bullet also says man made material | US 6.5 to 14, medium width |
| Crocs Santa Cruz Loafer | Slip on style loafer, casual | Canvas (bullets and facts block); the first description block names a different fabric | US 7 to 15 |
| Merrell Jungle Moc | Slip on shoe, moccasin in the spec table | Suede (material composition row) and leather (outer material row) | US 7 to 15, wide sizes named |
| Florsheim Milano | Dress loafer, moc toe | Leather | US 7 to 15, wide sizes named |
| Go Tour Leather Slip On Loafers | Slip on loafer, driving shoe | Leather | US 6 to 13 |
| FitVille Wide Fit Loafers | Wide fit loafer, slip on | Named two ways in the listing | US 8 to 15 wide, US 8 to 14 extra wide |
Best men's loafer overall: Rockport Classic Penny Loafer
Best men's loafer overall: the Rockport Classic Penny Loafer, because the leather penny loafer has a removable insole and truTECH heel cushioning, and the listing pairs it with a suit for the office or khakis for dinner.
The listing names the style the Classic Lite Penny Loafer and gives a leather outer material with a foam inner, a pull on closure and a business casual formality level. Its bullets describe truTECH Technology that absorbs shock and cushions the heel, removable insoles for customising the fit, and extended sizes and widths, and its description calls it a dress shoe with leather uppers and an EVA footbed. Sizes run from US 6.5 to US 16 with wide sizes named; the linked version is Black 2 in US 8.5. It holds 4.3 stars from 2,554 ratings across versions.
It suits the uses its description names: a business meeting, the office with a suit and a dinner with friends with khakis. The honest catch: the rating count covers every colour and size of this loafer, not only the black pair.
Best suede loafer: Go Tour Suede Leather Casual Loafers
Best suede loafer: the Go Tour Suede Leather Casual Loafers, because its bullets give it a suede calfskin upper (one bullet also says man made material), a leather insole and a rubber sole with a heel height of about 1.3 cm.
The bullets describe an upper of suede calfskin leather, a leather insole with a cushioned man made foot bed, a rubber sole, a medium width (B, M) and a heel height of about 1.3 cm, and call the shoe light, soft and breathable. They name the use as from the city to the beach and call it a classic loafer. The facts block gives a suede leather outer material, a leather inner and a rubber sole, and the spec table lists a pull on closure and a breathable feature. Sizes run from US 6.5 to US 14; the linked version is A Brown in US 11. It holds 4.3 stars from 4,797 ratings across versions.
It suits the use its bullets name, from the city to the beach, with a casual formality level in the spec table. The honest catch: the listing names a medium width only, and one bullet calls the build man made material beside the suede upper.
Best casual canvas loafer: Crocs Santa Cruz Loafer
Best casual canvas loafer: the Crocs Santa Cruz Loafer, because the slip on loafer has elastic goring at the sides and a Croslite midsole, and the listing says you can wear it like a loafer or fold the heels down like a slide.
The listing calls it a slip on style loafer for easy on and off, with a canvas upper that it describes as lightweight, elastic goring along the sides for a secure fit and a Croslite material midsole. Its facts block gives a canvas outer material and an ethylene vinyl acetate sole, though its first description block names a different upper fabric; its spec table gives a pull on closure, and its bullets add tiny nubs along the foot bed for a massage like feel. The size list runs from US 7 to US 15, and the linked version is Khaki/Khaki in US 11. It holds 4.6 stars from 25,416 ratings across versions.
It suits the uses its listing names: the office, casual days and easygoing outings around town. The honest catch: it is a casual loafer with a canvas upper in its bullets and facts block, rather than a leather dress shoe, and the listing says exposure to extreme heat, sun, dishwashers, washing machines or hot cars can cause the shoes to shrink or warp.
Best moc slip on shoe: Merrell Jungle Moc
Best moc slip on shoe: the Merrell Jungle Moc, because the listing pairs a pigskin lining and an Ortholite footbed with an air cushion in the heel for an everyday slip on.
The listing describes comfort features of a pigskin lining and an Ortholite anatomical footbed, a compression moulded EVA footframe for cushioning, and a Merrell air cushion in the heel that absorbs shock and adds stability, with a breathable mesh lining. Its maker's section calls the Jungle Moc a slip on shoe that combines style with engineered comfort. The facts block gives a rubber sole, with the outer material row reading leather and the material composition row reading suede, and the spec table lists a moccasin shoe type, a pull on closure and a casual formality level. Sizes run from US 7 to US 15, with wide sizes named for many of them; the linked version is Gunsmoke in US 10. It holds 4.6 stars from 24,644 ratings across colours and sizes.
It suits the everyday use its bullets name. The honest catch: the listing calls it a Jungle Moc slip on shoe and never a loafer, so its casual formality level reads more casual than the business casual of the Rockport and Florsheim spec tables, and its two material rows disagree on the upper.
Best dress loafer: Florsheim Milano
Best dress loafer: the Florsheim Milano, because the listing calls it a dress loafer with handsewn leather uppers, a breathable leather lining and a Comfortech cushioned insole.
The bullets describe leather uppers with handsewn construction and a metal bit accent, plus a breathable leather lining with a Comfortech cushioned insole. The description gives a soft leather upper and a decorative metal buckle, and its second block names the style the Milano Moc Toe Bit Loafer, with a hidden gore opening for a slip on fit. The spec table lists a moc toe, a pull on closure, daily wear and business casual. Sizes run from US 7 to US 15 with wide sizes named; the linked version is Black in US 8. It holds 4.3 stars from 1,275 ratings across versions.
It suits the uses its spec table names: daily wear and business casual. The honest catch: it is a moc toe bit loafer that the spec table lists for daily wear and business casual, and the listing names its trim two ways, a metal bit accent in the bullets and a decorative metal buckle in the description.
Best driving loafer: Go Tour Leather Slip On Loafers
Best driving loafer: the Go Tour Leather Slip On Loafers, because the listing sells this leather slip on as a driving shoe with a rubber outsole and stitched leather uppers.
The title calls it a casual slip on loafer and a driving shoe, and the spec table gives a driving sport type, a drive use, a plain toe, a flat heel and a pull on closure. The bullets describe a slip on design for quick and easy on and off, lightweight, flexible loafer leather uppers with detailed stitching throughout, and a rubber outsole the listing says gives traction on a variety of surfaces. The facts block gives leather outer and inner materials, and the spec table gives a felt insole. Sizes run from US 6 to US 13; the linked version is A/dark Brown in US 9. It holds 4.1 stars from 9,083 ratings across versions.
It suits the use its spec table names, driving, with a casual formality level. The honest catch: the rating sits at 4.1, lower than the other picks, and the count is shared across every colour of this style.
Best wide fit loafer: FitVille Wide Fit Loafers
Best wide fit loafer: the FitVille Wide Fit Loafers, because the listing is sold in wide and extra wide sizes with a roomy round toe, twin elastic panels and an OrthoLite cushioned insole.
The bullets describe a roomy round toe box that lets feet spread naturally, twin elastic panels for slip on wear without laces, a non slip lightweight rubber outsole and an insole with OrthoLite technology that absorbs shock. The spec table lists a pull on closure, a walking sport type and special features of lightweight, slip resistant and wide toe box. Sizes run from US 8 to US 15 in wide and US 8 to US 14 in extra wide; the linked version is Black in US 11.5 extra wide. It holds 4.2 stars from 1,616 ratings across versions.
It suits the uses its bullets name: walking, work and all day wear, with its description adding casual outings and semi formal events. The honest catch: the listing disagrees with itself on the upper, because its title and bullets name one upper material and its spec table names a different one, so this page names none.
How to choose a men's loafer
Two listings give business casual: the Rockport Classic Penny Loafer and the Florsheim Milano. The Crocs Santa Cruz Loafer, Merrell Jungle Moc and both Go Tour listings give a casual formality level, and the FitVille spec table lists a casual occasion lifestyle. The Rockport description calls its loafer a dress shoe to pair with a suit for the office, and the Florsheim description calls its Milano a dress loafer. Our men's dress shoes guide covers men's dress shoes, and our men's walking shoes guide covers walking shoes.
Which loafers are leather, suede or canvas?
The Rockport Classic Penny Loafer, Florsheim Milano and Go Tour Leather Slip On Loafers name a leather outer material, the Go Tour Suede Leather Casual Loafers name a suede leather outer material, and the Crocs Santa Cruz Loafer names a canvas outer material. Four listings disagree with themselves on the upper: the Merrell facts block reads suede in its material composition row and leather in its outer material row, the FitVille title and bullets name a different upper from its spec table, one Go Tour suede bullet calls the build man made material, and the first Crocs description block names a different fabric from its canvas bullets and facts block.
How do the sizes and widths compare?
Wide sizes are named in the Merrell Jungle Moc, Rockport Classic Penny Loafer, Florsheim Milano and FitVille Wide Fit Loafers listings, and the FitVille list adds extra wide in US 8 to US 14. The Rockport maker's section also names narrow, wide and extra wide sizes. The Go Tour suede listing names a medium width, and the Crocs and Go Tour driving size lists show no wide sizes. Every listing gives US sizes, and this page repeats them as listed.
What cushioning does each listing name?
Each listing names its own cushioning feature, and no listing compares it with another. Rockport names truTECH heel cushioning and removable insoles, Go Tour suede a cushioned man made foot bed, Crocs a Croslite material midsole, Merrell an Ortholite footbed and heel air cushion, Florsheim a Comfortech cushioned insole and FitVille an OrthoLite insole.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best brand of loafers for men?
The Rockport Classic Penny Loafer is the top pick here, at 4.3 stars from 2,554 ratings across versions. Crocs and Merrell hold the highest star rating, 4.6, with 25,416 ratings for the Crocs Santa Cruz Loafer and 24,644 for the Merrell Jungle Moc. Florsheim and Go Tour suede sit at 4.3, FitVille at 4.2 and Go Tour driving at 4.1.
What brand has the most comfortable loafers?
The Crocs Santa Cruz Loafer and Merrell Jungle Moc have the highest star ratings here, both 4.6, but no listing ranks comfort against another. The listings name different cushioning: a Croslite midsole for Crocs, an Ortholite footbed and heel air cushion for Merrell, truTECH heel cushioning for Rockport and a Comfortech insole for Florsheim.
Which loafers on this page suit the office?
The Rockport Classic Penny Loafer, whose listing pairs it with a suit for the office, and the Florsheim Milano, whose spec table lists business casual. The Crocs Santa Cruz Loafer description says it is refined enough to wear to the office, though its spec table gives a casual formality level. The FitVille bullets name work among their uses.
Is the Merrell Jungle Moc a loafer?
Not in its listing's words: the Merrell listing calls the Jungle Moc a slip on shoe, never a loafer, and its spec table gives the shoe type as moccasin. Like every pick on this page it has a pull on closure, and its spec table gives a casual formality level.
What is a driving loafer?
The Go Tour Leather Slip On Loafers is the driving loafer here: its spec table lists a driving sport type and a drive use, its bullets describe stitched leather uppers and a rubber outsole the listing says gives traction on a variety of surfaces, and its spec table gives a felt insole. Its 4.1 stars are the lowest here.
Are there wide fit loafers for men?
Yes: the FitVille Wide Fit Loafers listing is sold in wide and extra wide sizes with a roomy round toe. The Rockport Classic Penny Loafer, Florsheim Milano and Merrell Jungle Moc listings also name wide sizes, and the Go Tour suede listing names a medium width.
Which of these loafers are leather, suede or canvas?
The Rockport Classic Penny Loafer, Florsheim Milano and Go Tour Leather Slip On Loafers name a leather outer material. The Go Tour suede loafer names suede leather, though one bullet says man made material, and Crocs names canvas, though one description block names another fabric. The Merrell rows read suede and leather, and FitVille names two uppers.
Do the rating counts cover every colour and size?
Yes: each count on this page is the listing's own and covers every colour and size of that style. The Rockport Classic Penny Loafer's 2,554 ratings cover the whole style, not only the black pair, and the same holds for the 25,416 ratings across versions for the Crocs Santa Cruz Loafer and the 1,616 for the FitVille Wide Fit Loafers.