The best acoustic guitar strings for most people are the D'Addario EJ16 Phosphor Bronze Light 12 to 53, because its listing names a phosphor bronze set in light gauge sealed in corrosion resistant packaging for strings that are always fresh. This page compares seven string sets using only what each Amazon listing and its spec table state, plus the star rating and rating count shown for each.
Six of the seven are bronze wound steel sets for acoustic guitar. The seventh, the D'Addario EJ45, is a nylon set whose listing names classical guitar. Gauge, alloy and coating are given as each listing gives them, with the block of the listing named wherever two blocks disagree. This page covers strings only; our best guitar stands guide compares stands for the guitar itself. Other music guides here cover harmonicas and electronic drum kits.
| String set | Gauge (listing) | Alloy or material (listing) | Coating (listing) | Sets in the listing |
| D'Addario EJ16 | Light, 12 to 53 | Phosphor bronze | No coating named (spec table coating line reads bronze) | 1 set |
| Ernie Ball Earthwood Medium Light Phosphor Bronze | Medium Light, 12 to 54 | Phosphor bronze (92% copper, 7.7% tin, 0.3% phosphorus) | Uncoated (spec table) | 1 set |
| Elixir 16052 | Light, 12 to 53 | Phosphor bronze | Nanoweb (title, bullets, spec table coating line); spec table finish type reads Uncoated | 1 set |
| Martin Authentic Acoustic MA140 | Light, 12 to 54 | 80/20 bronze (bullets, model name); the title says only Bronze | Uncoated (spec table) | 1 set of 6 strings (bullets, spec table); one product description line names a 3 pack |
| Ernie Ball Earthwood Extra Light 80/20 Bronze | Extra Light, 10 to 50 | 80/20 bronze (80% copper, 20% zinc) | Uncoated (spec table) | 1 set |
| Elixir 16546 | Medium, 13 to 56 | Phosphor bronze | Nanoweb | 3 sets (3 pack) |
| D'Addario EJ45 Pro Arte Nylon | Normal tension (nylon set) | Nylon trebles, wound basses (bullets) | Spec table coating line reads silver; the maker's chart gives the bass wrap as silver plated copper, uncoated | 1 set |
Best acoustic guitar strings overall: D'Addario EJ16
Best acoustic guitar strings overall: the D'Addario EJ16 Phosphor Bronze Light, because the listing gives a phosphor bronze set in light gauge, 12 to 53, sealed in corrosion resistant packaging for strings that are always fresh.
The D'Addario EJ16 listing names a phosphor bronze set in light gauge, 12 to 53, as a single set (package quantity 1). Its bullets describe corrosion resistant packaging for strings that are always fresh. The maker's section describes phosphor bronze strings precision wound onto a hexagonally shaped high carbon steel core, with lasting, vivid sound and excellent intonation. It holds 4.7 stars from 37,696 ratings across versions.
It suits acoustic guitar, the use its spec table names. The honest catch: the listing names no coating (its spec table coating line reads only bronze), and its rating count is shown across versions, so it does not belong to this single set alone.
Best medium light phosphor bronze set: Ernie Ball Earthwood Medium Light Phosphor Bronze
Best medium light phosphor bronze set: the Ernie Ball Earthwood Medium Light Phosphor Bronze, because the listing says its 92% copper, 7.7% tin and 0.3% phosphorus wire gives a rich, expressive sound with excellent clarity, sealed in Element Shield packaging.
The Ernie Ball Earthwood Medium Light Phosphor Bronze listing names a Medium Light set with a gauge of 12 to 54, and its spec table lists the six strings as .012, .016, .024, .032, .044 and .054. The maker's section describes the phosphor bronze wire wrapped around brass plated hex shaped steel core wire, with a warm, rich sound and excellent clarity. The bullets name rich, expressive sound, excellent clarity and Element Shield packaging, which the listing says prolongs string life and keeps strings as fresh as the day they were made. The spec table's coating line reads Uncoated. It holds 4.7 stars from 18,175 ratings.
It suits acoustic guitar, the use its spec table names. The honest catch: the set is uncoated by its spec table, and the prolonged string life it describes for the Element Shield packaging is the listing's own statement.
Best Nanoweb coated light set: Elixir 16052
Best Nanoweb coated light set: the Elixir 16052 Phosphor Bronze Light, because the listing says its ultra thin Nanoweb coating keeps a traditionally textured, uncoated feel while protecting against common corrosion, on a light 12 to 53 set.
The Elixir 16052 listing names phosphor bronze wrap wire in light gauge, 12 to 53, as a single set. Its bullets describe a dynamic balance of rich, full bodied tone and sparkling high end clarity, and an ultra thin Nanoweb coating that provides a traditionally textured, uncoated feel while the patented coating technology protects against common corrosion. The listing credits that technology with extending tone life beyond any other brand's coated or uncoated strings and names an Elixir Strings player survey as the source. The coating blocks disagree: the title, the bullets and the spec table coating line name Nanoweb, while the spec table finish type line reads Uncoated. It holds 4.7 stars from 12,168 ratings.
It suits acoustic guitar, the use its spec table names. The honest catch: the tone life claim comes from Elixir's own player survey, as the listing notes, and the listing's own blocks disagree on whether the set is coated.
Best for bluegrass players: Martin Authentic Acoustic MA140
Best for bluegrass players: the Martin Authentic Acoustic Light 12 to 54, because the listing says its bright, punchy attack mellows as you play, making the pack ideal for bluegrass players, on a 12 to 54 set for fingerpicking and flat picking.
The Martin listing names a Light set, 12 to 54: the bullets say this set of 6 strings and the spec table counts 1 item, while one line of the product description names a 3 pack and another says the pack holds 6 light gauge strings. The alloy blocks differ: the title says only Bronze, while the bullets say Made from 80/20 bronze and the spec table model name reads MA140 Authentic Acoustic SP 80/20 Bronze Light Gauge. The bullets say the sound starts as a bright, punchy attack that quickly mellows as you play, and that the strings can be used for fingerpicking and flat picking. The spec table lists fingerpicking, flat picking and bluegrass among its recommended uses, and its coating line reads Uncoated. It holds 4.7 stars from 7,781 ratings.
It suits bluegrass, fingerpicking and flat picking, the uses its listing names. The honest catch: the title calls the alloy only Bronze, with 80/20 named in the bullets and the model name, and the listing calls 12 to 54 Light where the Ernie Ball listing calls the same numbers Medium Light.
Best extra light set: the Ernie Ball Earthwood Extra Light 80/20 Bronze, because this 10 to 50 set has the lowest gauge numbers of the six steel sets here, with 80/20 bronze wound strings the listing says give well balanced projection with crisp pleasing highs.
The Ernie Ball Earthwood Extra Light 80/20 Bronze listing names an Extra Light set with a gauge of 10 to 50 in its title and spec table. The bullets give the wound strings as 80% copper and 20% zinc wire, and the plain strings as specially tempered tin plated high carbon steel. The bullets say this alloy provides well balanced projection with crisp pleasing highs, and the maker's section describes a crisp, bright sound with pleasing overtones. The listing says the Element Shield packaging prolongs string life and keeps strings as fresh as the day they were made. The spec table coating line reads Uncoated. It holds 4.7 stars from 7,459 ratings.
It suits acoustic guitar, the use its spec table names. The honest catch: it uses 80/20 bronze rather than phosphor bronze, and the set is uncoated by its spec table.
Best medium gauge: Elixir 16546
Best medium gauge: the Elixir 16546 Phosphor Bronze Medium 3 Pack, because this pack gives three sets of 13 to 56 phosphor bronze strings with Nanoweb coating and anti rust plated plain strings that the listing says resist corrosion.
The Elixir 16546 listing names a 3 pack: its contents line names a pack containing three sets of strings, and its spec table counts 3 items. Each set is phosphor bronze with Nanoweb coating in Medium gauge, 13 to 56, and the bullets give the gauge as 013, 017, 026, 035, 045 and 056. The bullets add that the anti rust plated plain steel strings also resist tone deadening corrosion, ensuring longer life for the entire set. They say Elixir strings retain their tone longer than any other string, uncoated or coated, and cite an Elixir Strings player survey. It holds 4.8 stars from 572 ratings.
It suits acoustic guitar, the use its spec table names. The honest catch: its 13 to 56 gauge has the highest numbers of the six steel sets here, this listing is a 3 pack of sets, and the 4.8 rests on 572 ratings, the fewest of the seven.
Best nylon classical set: D'Addario EJ45 Pro Arte Nylon
Best nylon classical set: the D'Addario EJ45 Pro Arte Nylon Normal Tension, because the listing gives laser sorted clear nylon trebles for consistent, precise intonation and precision wound basses for warm, projecting tone.
The D'Addario EJ45 Pro Arte Nylon listing names a nylon set at Normal tension, and its spec table names classical guitar as the recommended use. The bullets say its normal tension offers balance of volume and comfortable resistance, with laser sorted clear nylon treble strings for consistent, precise intonation and precision wound basses for warm, projecting tone. The maker's chart column for this set lists a warm, traditional tone and a natural feel. The title and bullets give the tension as Normal, while the spec table lists a single string gauge figure rather than a set range, so this page gives no gauge numbers for it. It holds 4.6 stars from 28,708 ratings across versions.
It suits classical guitar, the use its listing names. The honest catch: it is a nylon set whose listing names classical guitar, not one of the steel acoustic sets the rest of this page covers.
How to choose acoustic guitar strings
What do the gauge numbers on a string set mean?
In these listings the gauge is shown as two numbers, such as 10 to 50, 12 to 53 or 13 to 56, matching the first and last of the six string figures the Ernie Ball spec table lists for its 12 to 54 set (.012 to .054). Set names vary by brand: the Ernie Ball maker's section lists Extra Light as 10 to 50, Light as 11 to 52, Medium Light as 12 to 54 and Medium as 13 to 56, the D'Addario and Elixir Light listings give 12 to 53, and the Martin listing calls 12 to 54 Light.
Phosphor bronze or 80/20 bronze?
Four picks are phosphor bronze by their listings: the D'Addario EJ16, the Ernie Ball Medium Light, the Elixir 16052 and the Elixir 16546. Two are 80/20 bronze: the Ernie Ball Extra Light and the Martin set, whose title says only Bronze. The listings pair phosphor bronze with warm, balanced or rich words (the D'Addario maker's section and the Ernie Ball maker's section) and 80/20 bronze with bright, crisp or punchy words (the Ernie Ball and Martin listings).
Coated or uncoated strings?
Two picks name Nanoweb coating: the Elixir 16052 and the Elixir 16546. The Ernie Ball and Martin spec tables read Uncoated, and the D'Addario EJ16 listing names no coating (its spec table coating line reads bronze). The Elixir 16052 spec table finish type line also reads Uncoated, so that listing's blocks disagree. The tone life claim for both Elixir sets rests on an Elixir Strings player survey, and packaging claims such as Element Shield are separate from coating.
One set or a 3 pack?
Six of the seven listings count 1 item in their spec tables; the Elixir 16546 is the 3 pack, with a pack containing three sets of strings by its contents line and an item count of 3 in its spec table.
Steel or nylon strings?
Six of the seven are bronze wound steel sets for acoustic guitar, and the D'Addario EJ45 is the nylon set, with classical guitar named as its recommended use.
How do the ratings compare?
All seven picks hold between 4.6 and 4.8 stars, and the rating counts run from 572 (Elixir 16546, 4.8) to 37,696 (D'Addario EJ16, 4.7, across versions). The D'Addario EJ45 holds 4.6 from 28,708 ratings across versions.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best acoustic guitar strings?
The D'Addario EJ16 Phosphor Bronze Light is the top pick here: its listing names a phosphor bronze set in light gauge, 12 to 53, in corrosion resistant packaging. The Ernie Ball Earthwood Medium Light Phosphor Bronze is the pick among medium light phosphor bronze sets, and the Elixir 16052 is the pick among Nanoweb coated light sets.
What is the difference between phosphor bronze and 80/20 bronze acoustic guitar strings?
The listings give different wire recipes and tone words. The Ernie Ball Medium Light phosphor bronze wire is 92% copper, 7.7% tin and 0.3% phosphorus, and its maker describes a warm, rich sound. The Ernie Ball Extra Light 80/20 bronze wire is 80% copper and 20% zinc, and its maker describes a crisp, bright sound.
Which acoustic guitar strings are coated?
The Elixir 16052 and the Elixir 16546 3 pack name Nanoweb coating. The Ernie Ball sets and the Martin set read Uncoated in their spec tables, and the D'Addario EJ16 listing names no coating (its spec table coating line reads bronze). The Elixir 16052 spec table also lists its finish type as Uncoated, so that listing's blocks disagree.
What gauge are light and medium acoustic guitar strings?
The listings give the Elixir 16052 and the D'Addario EJ16 as Light at 12 to 53, the Martin set as Light at 12 to 54, the Ernie Ball set as Medium Light at 12 to 54, and the Elixir 16546 as Medium at 13 to 56. Brands name the same numbers differently.
What are the best acoustic guitar strings for bluegrass?
The Martin Authentic Acoustic Light 12 to 54 is the pick: its bullets describe a bright, punchy attack that quickly mellows, making the pack ideal for bluegrass players, and its spec table lists bluegrass among recommended uses. Its alloy reads 80/20 bronze in the bullets and the model name, while the title says only Bronze.
What are the best extra light acoustic guitar strings?
The Ernie Ball Earthwood Extra Light 80/20 Bronze is the extra light pick here: its title and spec table give a gauge of 10 to 50, and the other five steel sets run from 12 to 56. The bullets describe well balanced projection with crisp pleasing highs, and its spec table coating line reads Uncoated.
Which of these strings are for classical guitar?
The D'Addario EJ45 Pro Arte Nylon is the classical guitar set: its spec table names classical guitar as the recommended use, and its bullets describe laser sorted clear nylon treble strings and precision wound basses. The other six picks are bronze wound steel sets whose listings are for acoustic guitar strings, not nylon.
Which acoustic guitar strings come as a 3 pack?
The Elixir 16546 is the 3 pack here: its contents line names a pack containing three sets of strings, each in Medium gauge, 13 to 56, phosphor bronze with Nanoweb coating. The other six picks each count 1 item in their spec tables, and the Elixir 16546 holds 4.8 stars from 572 ratings, the fewest of the seven.
What does the Elixir tone life claim rest on?
The Elixir 16052 and Elixir 16546 listings both name an Elixir Strings player survey as the source of their tone life claims. The 16052 listing says its coating extends tone life beyond any other brand's coated or uncoated strings, and the 16546 bullets say Elixir strings retain their tone longer. This page treats both as the maker's claims.