The best brow gel for most people is the e.l.f. Brow Lift in Clear, because its listing calls it an extreme hold eyebrow gel that lifts, sculpts and grooms every brow hair into place for fluffy, on trend soap brows. We compared seven brow gels from e.l.f., NYX Professional Makeup, L'Oreal Paris and Maybelline, clear, tinted and fibre, using only what each listing says and the ratings it shows.
Nothing here is a hands on test: the page compares listings. Brow pencils, brow tint and dye kits and salon lamination kits are not in the comparison. Our eyebrow pencil guide compares pencils; this page compares gels that lift, hold, tint or thicken brow hairs.
| Brow gel | Linked shade | Size or pack | Hold or wear words (listing) |
| e.l.f. Brow Lift | Clear | 10 ml (spec table unit count) | Extreme hold; long lasting hold; stays put all day (bullets) |
| e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow Mascara Gel | Clear | Pack of 2 (variation name and Number of Items row) | Dual sided flexible hold (title); all day hold without stiffness or flaking (bullets) |
| NYX The Brow Glue Tinted | Dark Brown | 5 g (spec table unit count); item weight row says 1 g | Extra strong, 16 hour extreme hold (bullets); holds up to 16 hours (description) |
| NYX Thick It Stick It | Taupe | 19.2 g (item weight and unit count rows) | Lasts up to 16 hours (bullets); 16 hour wear (description); no hold word |
| NYX Control Freak | Transparent in the bullets; Dark Mystic in the Colour row | 9 g (title and bullets) | Every hair sits in place, lasts all day (bullets); medium to strong hold (maker's section) |
| L'Oreal Paris Infallible Brow Lamination | Clear/Transparent | About 4.7 ml (spec table unit count) | Lifts and holds brows in place; up to 24 hours of wear (bullets) |
| Maybelline Super Lock Brow Glue | Clear | 7 ml (title and spec table) | Up to 24 hour super strong hold (bullets); up to 24 hours (description) |
Best brow gel overall: e.l.f. Brow Lift
Best brow gel overall: the e.l.f. Brow Lift in Clear, because its listing calls it an extreme hold eyebrow gel that lifts, sculpts and grooms every brow hair into place for fluffy soap brows, and it has the most ratings of the four 4.5 star picks.
The bullets call the e.l.f. Brow Lift an extreme hold eyebrow gel that instantly lifts, sculpts and grooms every brow hair into place, giving fluffy, on trend soap brows, and describe a conditioning formula that nourishes brow hairs while shaping. They promise long lasting hold and lifted, fluffy brows that stay put all day when applied with the Brow Lift Applicator, and say the spoolie is sold separately. On finish the blocks differ: the bullets say a clear, natural finish, while the spec table's Finish Type row says Matte. The spec table gives a tube with a unit count of 10 ml, and the listing says it is 100% vegan, cruelty free and Leaping Bunny certified. The linked listing is the Clear shade. It holds 4.5 stars from 14,436 ratings.
It suits the look its listing names, fluffy soap brows on all skin tones and brow colours. The honest catch: the listing says the spoolie is sold separately, and its bullets and spec table disagree on finish, a clear, natural finish against Matte.
Best clear lash and brow gel: e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow Mascara Gel
Best clear lash and brow gel: the e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow Mascara Gel, because its listing says the clear formula works as both lash definer and eyebrow grooming gel, shaping brows into place with all day hold without stiffness or flaking.
The title of the e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow Mascara Gel names a dual sided flexible hold, and the bullets say its clear mascara gel separates lashes and shapes brows into place for a clean, natural look. They describe a lightweight, clear formula with all day hold without stiffness or flaking and a flexible finish, a clear mascara primer that defines lashes without adding colour, and a base under brow pencils and mascara. The spec table lists a built in brush and a water repellent level. The listing's variation name, its Number of Items row and its description all give a pack of 2, and the title names no pack. It holds 4.5 stars from 7,360 ratings.
It suits the uses its listing names: brows and lashes, no makeup looks, and a base under brow pencils and mascara. The honest catch: it is a two in one lash and brow gel with a flexible hold, where the top pick is worded as an extreme hold gel, and its category on the listing is mascaras.
Best tinted brow gel: NYX The Brow Glue Tinted
Best tinted brow gel: the NYX The Brow Glue Tinted in Dark Brown, because its listing calls it a non sticky tinted eyebrow gel with extra strong, extreme hold that dries down with a natural finish and is flake resistant.
The bullets call the NYX The Brow Glue Tinted a non sticky and tinted eyebrow gel that gives extra strong, 16 hour extreme hold instantly, to style brow hairs and hold them in place, and say it acts as a brow mascara. They add that it is flake resistant and dries down with a natural finish. The product description says its glue like gel formula holds up to 16 hours. The spec table gives a natural finish, a unit count of 5 g and an item weight of 1 g, and its directions say to shape the eyebrows and secure them with The Brow Glue Brush. The linked listing is the Dark Brown shade; its options list names 05 Black, Dark Brown, Medium Brown and Taupe, while its bullets give a different shade count. It holds 4.3 stars from 10,906 ratings across versions.
It suits the use its listing names, styling brow hairs and holding them in place. The honest catch: the card links the Dark Brown shade only, its 10,906 ratings are shown across the shades and pack sizes of the listing, and its bullets say a 16 hour hold where the description says up to 16 hours.
Best thickening fibre brow gel: NYX Thick It Stick It
Best thickening fibre brow gel: the NYX Thick It Stick It in Taupe, because its listing calls it a thickening eyebrow gel with tinted plant origin fibres that build with each layer, with wear of up to 16 hours.
The bullets call the NYX Thick It Stick It a thickening eyebrow gel that tints, tames and thickens all types of eyebrows with a natural finish that lasts up to 16 hours, a vegan, ultra buildable tinted brow mascara with tinted plant origin fibres that take eyebrows further with each layer. The description adds hair like fibres for 16 hour wear and says it is flake, smudge and transfer resistant. The spec table gives a Matte finish, an item weight of 19.2 g and a unit count of 19.2 g, and its directions say to apply it like mascara and allow it to dry. The linked listing is the Taupe shade. It holds 4.3 stars from 18,071 ratings.
It suits the people its listing names, all types of eyebrows. The honest catch: the listing never uses the word hold, so it reads as a tint and thickening gel rather than a gel that locks hairs in place, and its bullets say a natural finish where its spec table says Matte.
Best transparent brow gel for taming: NYX Control Freak
Best transparent brow gel for taming: the NYX Control Freak, because its listing calls it a non sticky transparent eyebrow gel that helps you brush your brows and ensures every hair sits in place, on its own or after colouring your brows, and it has the most ratings here.
The title calls the NYX Control Freak an eyebrow gel for taming and defining that helps you brush your brows, ensures every hair sits in place and lasts all day, in a non sticky, vegan formula of 9 g. The bullets call it a transparent eyebrow gel that can be used on its own or combined with other eyebrow products, and say to apply it after colouring your brows or on its own. The maker's section says a medium to strong hold with a flake free finish and adds that it can define and emphasise lashes without colouring them. The colour and finish blocks disagree: the bullets and the maker's section call it transparent, while the spec table's Colour row says Dark Mystic and its Finish Type row says Shimmery. It holds 4.2 stars from 42,766 ratings.
It suits the uses its listing names: on its own, after colouring your brows or with other eyebrow products. The honest catch: its 4.2 stars are the lowest of the seven picks, and its bullets make no hold claim beyond every hair sitting in place and lasting all day, though the maker's section says medium to strong hold.
Best brow lamination gel: L'Oreal Paris Infallible Brow Lamination
Best brow lamination gel: the L'Oreal Paris Infallible Brow Lamination, because its listing says the lightweight gel lifts and holds brows in place for up to 24 hours of wear and resists sweat and water with no sticky residue.
The bullets call the L'Oreal Paris Infallible Brow Lamination a salon inspired, lightweight and easy to use gel that lifts and holds brows in place, creating lifted and fuller looking eyebrows with up to 24 hours of wear. They add a sweat and water resistant formula with no sticky texture or residue left behind, and an angled applicator swiped in upward strokes. The spec table gives a Natural finish and a unit count of about 4.7 ml. The linked listing is the Clear/Transparent shade. It holds 4.5 stars from 5,979 ratings.
It suits the uses its listing names: on its own or with your usual eyebrow makeup items. The honest catch: it is a single tube of lifting gel described as salon inspired, not a salon lamination kit.
Best clear brow glue: Maybelline Super Lock Brow Glue
Best clear brow glue: the Maybelline Super Lock Brow Glue in Clear, because its listing promises an up to 24 hour super strong hold with a transparent, non sticky finish that is flake resistant and sweat proof.
The bullets for the Maybelline Super Lock Brow Glue promise sculpted and styled brows locked in, an up to 24 hour super strong hold, a transparent finish with no residue, a non sticky and lightweight formula, flake resistant and sweat proof wear and a brush for precise styling. The description calls it a clear styling gel for the laminated brow look and says the hold lasts up to 24 hours. The title gives 7 ml, and the spec table gives an item weight of 14.1 g and a Natural finish, though its Item Form row says Liquid where the title and description say gel. The linked listing is the Clear shade. It holds 4.5 stars from 3,099 ratings.
It suits the use its listing names, sculpting and styling brows. The honest catch: it has the fewest ratings of the seven picks, 3,099 against 5,979 or more for each of the others.
How to choose a brow gel
Clear, transparent or tinted
Five of the seven listings describe a clear or transparent gel and two are tinted: the NYX The Brow Glue Tinted in Dark Brown and the NYX Thick It Stick It in Taupe. The e.l.f. Brow Lift, the e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow gel and the Maybelline Super Lock name Clear, and the L'Oreal Infallible names Clear/Transparent. The NYX Control Freak bullets call it transparent, although its spec table's Colour row says Dark Mystic. The tinted listings each link one shade here: the Brow Glue Tinted options list names 05 Black, Dark Brown, Medium Brown and Taupe, while its bullets give a different shade count, and the Thick It Stick It options list names Ash Blonde, Ash Brown, Auburn, Black, Blonde, Cool Ash Brown, Espresso, Rich Auburn and Taupe, while its bullets and description say 8 shades.
How the listings word hold
The listings word hold differently, and every phrase is the listing's own claim rather than a measured result. The e.l.f. Brow Lift says extreme hold, the Brow Glue Tinted says extra strong, 16 hour extreme hold, the Maybelline says up to 24 hour super strong hold and the e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow gel says flexible hold. The L'Oreal Infallible says it lifts and holds brows in place, the Control Freak bullets say every hair sits in place, with a medium to strong hold in the maker's section, and the Thick It Stick It listing uses no hold word.
Finish wording across listing blocks
Three listings give one finish in their bullets and another in their spec table. The e.l.f. Brow Lift bullets say a clear, natural finish where its spec table says Matte, the NYX Thick It Stick It bullets say a natural finish where its spec table says Matte, and the NYX Control Freak bullets say transparent where its spec table says Shimmery. The Brow Glue Tinted bullets and spec table both say natural, and the L'Oreal Infallible and Maybelline spec tables both say Natural.
Fibre gel for fuller looking brows
The NYX Thick It Stick It is the only listing here that names fibres: its bullets describe tinted plant origin fibres that build with each layer, and its description adds hair like fibres. The L'Oreal Infallible instead says its gel creates lifted and fuller looking eyebrows, and the e.l.f. Brow Lift says lifted, fluffy brows. The other listings describe setting or holding brow hairs, with no fibre or thickening wording.
A gel on its own or with other brow products
Five listings say how the gel works with other brow makeup. The L'Oreal Infallible bullets say to use it on its own or with your usual eyebrow makeup items, and the Control Freak bullets say it can be used on its own or combined with other eyebrow products, applied after colouring your brows. The e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow bullets describe a base under brow pencils and mascara, the Maybelline description says it can be used alone or layered over pencils and powders, and the Brow Glue Tinted directions say to fill sparse areas with eyebrow product.
Applicators and what comes with the gel
The listings name their applicators in different ways, and the e.l.f. Brow Lift is the only one that says an accessory is sold separately. Its bullets refer to the Brow Lift Applicator and say the spoolie is sold separately. The Control Freak directions say to use the brush provided, the Brow Glue Tinted directions name The Brow Glue Brush, the L'Oreal Infallible bullets name an angled applicator and the Maybelline bullets name a brush for precise styling. The e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow spec table lists a built in brush, and the Thick It Stick It bullets say a precise mascara application.
Gels that also name lashes
Two listings name lash use as well as brows: the e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow Mascara Gel and the NYX Control Freak. The e.l.f. bullets say it works as both lash definer and eyebrow grooming gel, and the Control Freak maker's section says it can define and emphasise lashes without colouring them. Our mascara guide compares mascaras for readers who want a lash product on its own.
Vegan and cruelty free statements
Five listings make a vegan or cruelty free statement and two do not. The e.l.f. Brow Lift says 100% vegan, cruelty free and Leaping Bunny certified, and the e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow says vegan, double certified cruelty free by Leaping Bunny and PETA. The Brow Glue Tinted bullets say PETA certified cruelty free, the Thick It Stick It bullets say vegan and the Control Freak bullets say a vegan formula. The L'Oreal Infallible and Maybelline listings do not use the words vegan or cruelty free.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best brow gel in Australia?
The e.l.f. Brow Lift in Clear is the best brow gel for most people here: its listing calls it an extreme hold eyebrow gel that lifts, sculpts and grooms every brow hair into place, and it holds 4.5 stars from 14,436 ratings. The NYX Control Freak has the most ratings of the seven, 42,766 at 4.2 stars.
What is the best clear brow gel in Australia?
The e.l.f. Brow Lift in Clear leads the clear gels, with its extreme hold wording and 4.5 stars from 14,436 ratings. The e.l.f. Clear Lash and Brow Mascara Gel adds a lash use, the Maybelline Super Lock Brow Glue states an up to 24 hour super strong hold, and the L'Oreal Infallible is listed as Clear/Transparent.
What is the best tinted brow gel in Australia?
The NYX The Brow Glue Tinted in Dark Brown is the best tinted brow gel here: its bullets call it a non sticky tinted eyebrow gel with extra strong, 16 hour extreme hold, rated 4.3 from 10,906 ratings across versions. The NYX Thick It Stick It in Taupe is the other tinted pick, with fibres.
Which brow gel has the most ratings?
The NYX Control Freak has the most ratings of the seven picks, 42,766 at 4.2 stars, which is also the lowest star rating here. The NYX Thick It Stick It follows with 18,071 ratings at 4.3 stars, and the e.l.f. Brow Lift has 14,436 ratings at 4.5 stars, the most among the four 4.5 star picks.
What is the best brow gel for sparse eyebrows?
The NYX Thick It Stick It in Taupe is the pick whose listing talks about thickening: it calls it a thickening eyebrow gel with tinted plant origin fibres that build with each layer. The L'Oreal Infallible listing also says its gel creates lifted and fuller looking eyebrows, and it holds 4.5 stars from 5,979 ratings.
Does brow gel actually make a difference?
The listings describe a brow gel as changing how brow hairs look and sit: the e.l.f. Brow Lift lifts and sculpts them, the NYX Control Freak sets every hair in place and the tinted NYX gels add colour. None of the seven listings claims to grow brows, and each result is the listing's own claim.
How long do brow gels last?
The listings state 16 hours for the NYX The Brow Glue Tinted and the NYX Thick It Stick It, up to 24 hours for the L'Oreal Infallible and the Maybelline Super Lock, and all day for the two e.l.f. gels and the NYX Control Freak. These are the listings' own wear claims, not measured results.