Best Eyeliner in Australia 2027: 8 Liquid, Pencil and Gel Eyeliners Compared
By Anish Puri·Last checked 20 November 2026·9 min read
The best eyeliner for most people is the NYX Epic Ink Liner: a liquid pen whose thin brush tip draws fine lines to bold wings, in a formula listed as vegan and waterproof. For brown kohl, the wet n wild kohl pencil in Simma Brown, and for a waterproof pencil, the Revlon ColorStay, listed at up to 24 hours.
The best eyeliner for most people is the NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner in Black, because the listing says its thin brush tip pen draws anything from fine lines to bold fish tail wings, in a formula it calls vegan and waterproof. We compared 8 eyeliners from 6 brands, liquid, pencil and gel, using only each Amazon Australia listing's words and star rating.
Sebum resistant 36 hours (bullets); up to 36 hours (maker)
Waterproof, no smudging, no fading
Satin
Maybelline HyperEasy
Brush tip liquid liner, flex tip
Pitch Black
Up to 24 hours
Waterproof (spec table); water resistant (benefits)
Satin
Best eyeliner overall: NYX Epic Ink Liner
Best eyeliner overall: the NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner in Black, because the listing says its thin brush tip pen draws anything from fine lines to bold fish tail wings, in a vegan, waterproof formula.
Top pick
NYX Professional Makeup
NYX Epic Ink Liner
The NYX Epic Ink Liner listing describes a liquid eyeliner pen in Black with a thin brush tip that draws fine lines to bold fish tail wings, in a vegan, waterproof, highly pigmented formula with a matte finish. It is rated 4.4 from 92,326 ratings across 8 Epic Ink shades.
$10.39$21.99
Save 53%
Amazon.com.au price as of 01:55 am AEDT, subject to change
As an Amazon Associate, NestPath earns from qualifying purchases.
The bullets say the pressure and angle of the brush set the thickness of the line. The product description adds smudge proof, lifeproof, a matte finish and use on face and body. The Contents line gives 0.2 g, while the product details give 13.49 g. It holds 4.4 stars from 92,326 ratings across 8 Epic Ink shades, the most of any eyeliner here.
It suits the fine lines, bold wings and graphic eye looks its listing names. The honest catch: the listing says longwearing but gives no hours figure, and three picks here rate higher at 4.6 stars.
Best brown kohl pencil: wet n wild Kohl Eyeliner Pencil in Simma Brown
Best brown kohl pencil: the wet n wild Kohl Eyeliner Pencil in Simma Brown Now!, because its title lists rich, hyper pigmented colour, a smooth, creamy application and a long wearing matte finish.
Runner-up
Wet n Wild
wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Pencil
This wet n wild kohl eyeliner pencil in Simma Brown Now!, a brown shade, is titled for rich, hyper pigmented colour, a smooth, creamy application, a long wearing matte finish and a cruelty free formula. It is rated 4.6 from 14,669 ratings across 4 shades.
$7.10
Amazon.com.au price as of 01:54 am AEDT, subject to change
As an Amazon Associate, NestPath earns from qualifying purchases.
Every fact here comes from the listing title, which also says cruelty free. It holds 4.6 stars from 14,669 ratings across 4 shades, the top star rating on this page, shared with the Revlon ColorStay and COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus.
It suits a brown kohl line with a matte finish, as its title describes. The honest catch: Simma Brown is a brown shade, not black, and the listing makes no waterproof claim and gives no wear hours.
Best retractable gel eyeliner: wet n wild Mega Last Retractable Eyeliner
Best retractable gel eyeliner: the wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Eyeliner in Black, because the listing says its satin gel formula glides onto lids without tugging and is smudge proof, flake proof and cry proof for up to 16 hours.
Also great
Wet n Wild
wet n wild Mega Last Retractable Eyeliner
The wet n wild Mega Last listing describes a waterproof retractable gel eyeliner in Black with a satin gel formula that glides on without tugging, smudge proof, flake proof and cry proof for up to 16 hours. It is rated 4.4 from 37,357 ratings across colours.
$11.99
Amazon.com.au price as of 01:55 am AEDT, subject to change
As an Amazon Associate, NestPath earns from qualifying purchases.
The bullets call it a silky, waterproof retractable gel eyeliner that is lightweight and comfortable, and the product description adds humidity proof. The title gives 0.23 g, while the product details give 4.54 g. It holds 4.4 stars from 37,357 ratings across its colours.
It suits the bold looks the listing names. The honest catch: its 16 hours is fewer than the up to 24 hours on the Revlon ColorStay and Maybelline HyperEasy listings.
Best kohl pencil for a smudged look: Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal Pencil
Best kohl pencil for a smudged look: the Rimmel London Soft Kohl Kajal Eye Liner Pencil in Jet Black, because the listing says its dense colour blends easily into the eyelid for a soft, smudged look, with wear up to 12 hours.
Also great
Rimmel
Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal Pencil
The Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal listing describes a Jet Black pencil whose dense colour blends easily into the eyelid for a soft, smudged look, with a long wear finish up to 12 hours. Its bullets call the colour smudgeable and its description calls the formula smudge proof. It is rated 4.4 from 27,837 ratings.
$4.24$8.95
Save 53%
Amazon.com.au price as of 01:54 am AEDT, subject to change
As an Amazon Associate, NestPath earns from qualifying purchases.
The bullets describe soft, smudgeable colour with staying power and a soft, smooth texture that goes on easily. The maker's section says the line can be blended even with a fingertip for a smokey eye and calls the pencil perfect for every day. The spec table gives a unit count of 1.2 g and an item weight of 4 g. It holds 4.4 stars from 27,837 ratings.
It suits the soft, smudged and smokey looks the listing names. The honest catch: the bullets call the colour smudgeable while the product description calls the formula smudge proof, and no block calls it waterproof.
Best transfer proof pencil: Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner
Best transfer proof pencil: the Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner in 201 Black, because the listing says it is transfer proof, waterproof, smudge proof and fade proof for up to 24 hours, with a built in sharpener and a smudger to blend.
Also great
Revlon
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner
The Revlon ColorStay listing describes a 201 Black pencil that is transfer proof, waterproof, smudge proof and fade proof for up to 24 hours, with a built in sharpener and a smudger. The title says 2 Pack; the spec table lists 1 item. It is rated 4.6 from 8,346 ratings across colours.
$21.07$25.00
Save 16%
Amazon.com.au price as of 01:55 am AEDT, subject to change
As an Amazon Associate, NestPath earns from qualifying purchases.
The bullets describe lines that go from subtle to dramatic, and the title adds an ultra fine tip. The directions describe twisting the pencil for colour at the tip and using the smudger for a softer, smoky look. It holds 4.6 stars from 8,346 ratings across its colours.
It suits looks from subtle to dramatic, as the listing names them. The honest catch: the title says 2 Pack while the spec table lists the number of items as 1.
Best quick dry liquid liner: COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Liquid Eyeliner
Best quick dry liquid liner: the COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Liquid Eyeliner in 200 Black Onyx, because the listing says its highly pigmented matte formula dries fast and its precise tip draws fine lines without tugging, smudging or multiple coats.
Also great
COVERGIRL
COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Liquid Eyeliner
The COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus listing describes a 2.5 ml matte liquid eyeliner in 200 Black Onyx with a precise tip for fine lines that does not tug or smudge, and a quick dry formula that lasts for 12 hours. It is rated 4.6 from 4,266 ratings.
$8.08$17.95
Save 55%
Amazon.com.au price as of 01:55 am AEDT, subject to change
As an Amazon Associate, NestPath earns from qualifying purchases.
The bullets give 12 hours of wear, and the product description adds that it won't fade or flake. The title gives 2.5 ml, and the listing says Covergirl products are Leaping Bunny Certified by Cruelty Free International. It holds 4.6 stars from 4,266 ratings.
It suits fine lines in one coat, as the listing names. The honest catch: its 12 hours is half the 24 on the Revlon and HyperEasy listings, and its 4,266 ratings are the fewest here.
Best sebum resistant gel pencil: Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel Pencil
Best sebum resistant gel pencil: the Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel Eyeliner Pencil in Deep Onyx, because the bullets say it gives intense eye definition in one stroke, is waterproof with no smudging or fading, and is sebum resistant for 36 hours.
Also great
Maybelline
Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel Pencil
The Maybelline Tattoo Liner listing describes a Deep Onyx gel eyeliner pencil with a built in sharpener that gives intense definition in one stroke, waterproof with no smudging or fading and sebum resistant for 36 hours. It is rated 4.3 from 12,938 ratings.
$8.49$19.99
Save 58%
Amazon.com.au price as of 01:55 am AEDT, subject to change
As an Amazon Associate, NestPath earns from qualifying purchases.
The bullets add a built in sharpener. The maker's section gives up to 36 hour wear and calls the gel pencils sweat resistant and smudge resistant, in 11 shades. The spec table lists a satin finish. It holds 4.3 stars from 12,938 ratings.
It suits the upper and bottom lash lines, which its directions name. The honest catch: its 4.3 stars tie with the Maybelline HyperEasy as the lowest star rating on this page.
Best flex tip brush liner for control: Maybelline HyperEasy Liquid Liner
Best flex tip brush liner for control: the Maybelline HyperEasy Brush Tip Liquid Liner in Pitch Black, because the listing pairs a flex tip brush with a custom hexagonal grip for control, and colour that lasts up to 24 hours.
Also great
Maybelline
Maybelline HyperEasy Liquid Liner
The Maybelline HyperEasy listing describes a Pitch Black liquid liner with a flex tip brush and a custom hexagonal grip for control, and intense colour that lasts up to 24 hours. Its spec table says waterproof and its benefits row says water resistant. It is rated 4.3 from 65,138 ratings across colours.
$10.49$19.99
Save 48%
Amazon.com.au price as of 01:55 am AEDT, subject to change
As an Amazon Associate, NestPath earns from qualifying purchases.
The bullets describe smooth application with no skips, slips, gaps or struggle, and the maker's section gives steps for a winged look. The directions say to let the liner dry for 20 seconds. It holds 4.3 stars from 65,138 ratings across its colours.
It suits the winged look its maker's section names. The honest catch: the spec table says waterproof while the Product benefits row says water resistant, and it ties for the lowest star rating here.
How to choose an eyeliner
Liquid, pencil or gel eyeliner
The type sets the line each listing describes: the liquid liners here describe fine, precise lines and wings, the Rimmel kohl a soft, smudged look, and the gel liners a formula that glides on with intense colour or definition. The Maybelline Tattoo Liner is both a pencil and a gel: its listing calls it a gel eyeliner pencil.
Waterproof, smudge proof and the words in between
Four listings call the eyeliner waterproof wherever they mention water: the NYX Epic Ink, wet n wild Mega Last, Revlon ColorStay and Maybelline Tattoo Liner.
The Maybelline HyperEasy says waterproof in its spec table and water resistant in its Product benefits row. The Rimmel bullets call the colour smudgeable while its product description says smudge proof. The COVERGIRL listing says no smudge and no flaking without the word waterproof, and the wet n wild kohl pencil title makes no water claim.
Black, brown and other shades
Six of the eight cards open on a shade with Black in its name, the Maybelline Tattoo Liner opens on Deep Onyx, and the wet n wild kohl pencil opens on Simma Brown Now!, a brown.
For other shades, the Mega Last and Revlon listings name Black Brown, the HyperEasy Brown, the COVERGIRL espresso, and the NYX 03 Dark Chocolate and Brunette among their options.
Brush tips, sharpeners and smudgers
The NYX Epic Ink and Maybelline HyperEasy have brush tips built in, the Revlon ColorStay and Maybelline Tattoo Liner have built in sharpeners, and the Revlon adds a smudger to blend.
The COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus lists a precise tip and the Mega Last is retractable. Separate eyeliner brushes are a different buy, and our makeup brush guide compares full brush sets.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best pencil eyeliner in Australia?
The Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner is the best transfer proof pencil here: its listing says transfer proof, waterproof, smudge proof and fade proof for up to 24 hours, with a built in sharpener. The Maybelline Tattoo Liner gel pencil lists up to 36 hour wear, and the Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal up to 12 hours.
Is liquid or pencil eyeliner easier for beginners?
The Maybelline HyperEasy Liquid Liner lists easy application with a flex tip brush and a hexagonal grip for control. The Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal pencil says it goes on easily, and the NYX Epic Ink bullets say brush pressure and angle set the thickness of the line. No listing here names beginners.
What is the best eyeliner that stays on all day?
The Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel Pencil gives the highest figure here: sebum resistant for 36 hours in its bullets and up to 36 hour wear in its maker's section. The Revlon ColorStay and Maybelline HyperEasy list up to 24 hours, the wet n wild Mega Last up to 16, and the Rimmel and COVERGIRL liners 12.
What is the best liquid eyeliner?
The NYX Epic Ink Liner is the best liquid eyeliner here, a thin brush tip pen that the listing says draws fine lines to bold fish tail wings in a vegan, waterproof formula. The COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus lists a quick dry matte formula for 12 hours, and the Maybelline HyperEasy a flex tip brush for up to 24.
Are eyeliner and kajal the same?
Kajal is sold as a kind of eyeliner on this page. The Rimmel listing titles its pencil a Soft Kohl Kajal Eye Liner Pencil, and its maker's section calls it both a kohl pencil and a kajal. The wet n wild pencil in Simma Brown is titled a Kohl Eyeliner Pencil. Both are pencils, not liquid liners.
How long does eyeliner take to dry?
The Maybelline HyperEasy directions say to let the liquid liner dry for 20 seconds, and its maker's section says about 20 seconds. The COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus listing calls its formula quick dry and says it dries fast, and the NYX Epic Ink description says it dries down to a matte finish.
Which eyeliner brand is best?
NYX holds the best eyeliner overall here, the Epic Ink Liner, with 92,326 ratings across 8 Epic Ink shades, the most on this page. Six brands share the 8 picks, and Maybelline and wet n wild have two picks each. The top rating, 4.6 stars, goes to the wet n wild kohl pencil, Revlon and COVERGIRL.
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, NestPath earns from qualifying purchases. This means if you click a product link and buy something, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely believe will help new homeowners. This does not influence our recommendations.
CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED ‘AS IS’ AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.