The best hiking boot for most people is the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped, a women's mid cut boot, because the listing pairs a seam sealed, waterproof leather and suede build with an Omni Grip rubber outsole and a reinforced toe and heel. We compared seven listings, four mid cut boots and three low cut hiking shoes for men and women, using only each Amazon Australia listing, its spec table and its star rating.
Ratings are shared across each listing's sizes and colours. For a building site rather than a trail, our work boots guide compares boots made for that job.
| Pick | Cut as listed | Upper | Water protection as listed | Outsole | US Wide sizes |
|---|
| Columbia Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped, women's | Mid top boot | Leather and suede | Waterproof in title and bullets | Omni Grip rubber | Yes |
| Columbia Crestwood, men's | Low top shoe | Leather, mesh and webbing | Mixed: breathable in title, waterproof in spec table | Omni Grip | Yes |
| Columbia Newton Ridge Plus 2 Suede, men's | Ankle high boot | Suede and synthetic | Waterproof membrane bootie | Omni Grip rubber | Yes |
| Merrell Moab 3 Mid GTX, men's | Ankle high boot | Pig suede leather and mesh | GORE TEX membrane | Vibram | Yes |
| Salomon X Ultra Pioneer Mid GTX, men's | Mid top, 409 g | Leather and textile | GORE TEX membrane | Two types of rubber | not stated |
| Merrell Moab 3, men's | Low top shoe | Pigskin leather and mesh | Not water resistant | Vibram rubber | Named on the listing |
| Merrell Moab 3 GTX, women's | Low top shoe | Pigskin leather and mesh | GORE TEX membrane | Vibram TC5+ rubber | not stated |
Best hiking boots overall: Columbia Women's Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped
Best hiking boots overall: the Columbia Women's Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped, because the listing pairs seam sealed waterproof leather and suede with an Omni Grip outsole and a reinforced toe and heel.
The listing describes a durable mid cut waterproof hiker with a TECHLITE lightweight midsole for cushioning and high energy return and an Omni Grip non marking rubber outsole for grip across a wide variety of terrain and three season use. The toe and heel are reinforced and the outsole toe overwrap extended. It holds 4.6 stars from 5,974 ratings across versions.
It suits women who want one waterproof mid boot, backed by more ratings than any other boot here. The honest catch: this is the women's boot, so men should see the Newton Ridge Plus 2 Suede below, and its spec table says water resistant although the title and bullets say waterproof.
Best low cut hiking shoe for men: Columbia Men's Crestwood
Best low cut hiking shoe for men: the Columbia Men's Crestwood, because the listing pairs a leather, mesh and webbing upper with a TechLite midsole, an Omni Grip outsole and wide fit.
The Crestwood is a low cut hiking shoe for men, not a boot. The listing calls it a nimble, all purpose hiker with a TechLite midsole for cushioning and high energy return and an indoor friendly Omni Grip non marking outsole for sure footed traction in the wild. The title adds high traction, lightweight and breathable. It holds 4.5 stars from 11,522 ratings across versions, the most of any pick here.
It suits men who want an all purpose low hiker, and men with wide feet. The honest catch: it covers less of the ankle than the boots here, and the listing is mixed on water: breathable in the title, waterproof in the spec table.
Best suede hiking boot for men: Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus 2 Suede
Best suede hiking boot for men: the Columbia Men's Newton Ridge Plus 2 Suede, because the listing pairs a suede upper with a seam sealed waterproof breathable membrane and an Omni Grip outsole.
This is a men's ankle high Newton Ridge Plus. The listing describes a suede and synthetic upper with metal hardware, an Omni Tech waterproof breathable seam sealed membrane bootie, a Techlite midsole of lightweight responsive foam, and an Omni Grip non marking rubber outsole. It holds 4.6 stars from 2,535 ratings across versions.
It suits men who want the top pick's Newton Ridge Plus name in a men's waterproof suede boot. The honest catch: it has fewer than half the ratings of the women's boot above, and its spec table says water resistant while the bullets describe a waterproof membrane.
Best waterproof mid boot for men: Merrell Men's Moab 3 Mid GTX
Best waterproof mid boot for men: the Merrell Men's Moab 3 Mid GTX, because the listing pairs a GORE TEX membrane with a Vibram sole and an abrasion resistant rubber heel and toe cap.
The listing describes a GORE TEX waterproof membrane for exceptional breathability and waterproof performance, a pig suede leather and breathable mesh upper and a protective, abrasion resistant rubber heel and toe cap. The spec table names Vibram as the sole material and lists the boot as waterproof. It holds 4.6 stars from 465 ratings across versions.
It suits men who want a mid boot listed as waterproof throughout, for wet tracks. The honest catch: 465 ratings is the smallest count on this page.
Best mid boot for climbs and descents: Salomon Men's X Ultra Pioneer Mid GTX
Best mid boot for climbs and descents: the Salomon Men's X Ultra Pioneer Mid GTX, because the listing pairs GORE TEX with SensiFit hold for downhills and two types of rubber for mud, at a listed 409 g.
Salomon calls it a versatile hiking shoe for climbs, descents and everyday adventures. Two types of rubber and a patterned heel area give more control in mud, the GORE TEX membrane keeps the wet out, a reinforced SensiFit construction holds the foot on tough downhills, the Advanced Chassis stabilises the heel and the higher cut wraps the ankle for extra protection. The spec table gives an item weight of 409 g without naming the size. It holds 4.4 stars from 3,195 ratings across versions.
It suits men on tracks with long climbs and descents. The honest catch: 4.4 stars is the lowest score here, and Salomon calls it a hiking shoe whose higher cut wraps the ankle, rather than a boot.
Best mesh hiking shoe for grip: Merrell Men's Moab 3
Best mesh hiking shoe for grip: the Merrell Men's Moab 3, because the listing pairs a Vibram rubber outsole with a pigskin leather and mesh upper and a protective toe cap.
The listing describes a premium Vibram rubber outsole it calls slip resistant enough to grip challenging surfaces, wet or dry, under a pigskin leather and mesh upper with a bellows tongue, a protective toe cap, a removable Kinetic Fit ADVANCED contoured insole and a lightweight EVA foam midsole. The spec table lists a low top and not water resistant. It holds 4.6 stars from 5,050 ratings across versions.
It suits men who want a low cut shoe with a Vibram outsole. The honest catch: this version is not water resistant, so for wet tracks men should look at the Moab 3 Mid GTX above.
Best waterproof hiking shoe for women: Merrell Women's Moab 3 GTX
Best waterproof hiking shoe for women: the Merrell Women's Moab 3 GTX, because the listing pairs a GORE TEX membrane with a pigskin leather and mesh upper and a Vibram TC5+ sole.
The women's low cut Moab 3 has a GORE TEX waterproof membrane for exceptional breathability and waterproof performance, a pigskin leather and mesh upper, a bellows tongue that keeps out debris, a protective toe cap and a Vibram TC5+ rubber sole. The spec table lists lightweight and waterproof as special features. It holds 4.5 stars from 862 ratings across versions.
It suits women who want a waterproof shoe rather than a boot. The honest catch: it covers less of the ankle than the women's Newton Ridge Plus, on a modest 862 ratings.
How to choose hiking boots
Hiking boots or hiking shoes
Choose a mid cut boot to cover the ankle and a low cut shoe to leave it free. Both Newton Ridge Plus boots, the Moab 3 Mid GTX and the Salomon are mid or ankle high; the Crestwood, Moab 3 and Moab 3 GTX are low top shoes. Our hiking backpack guide covers the pack to go with them.
Waterproof membrane or mesh
For wet tracks, choose a listing that names a waterproof membrane. The three GTX picks use GORE TEX and the Newton Ridge Plus 2 Suede an Omni Tech membrane bootie; the Moab 3 is marked not water resistant and the Crestwood listing is mixed.
Outsole and grip
The outsoles differ by brand: all three Merrell picks use Vibram, Columbia uses its own Omni Grip rubber, and Salomon two types of rubber with a patterned heel area for mud.
Sizes and wide feet
Choose your size from the size chart on each listing, because the charts differ: Merrell and Salomon give AU, UK, US and EU sizes, the Columbia men's charts UK, US and EU, and the women's Newton Ridge Plus UK and EU. The Columbia and Merrell men's charts add heel to toe length in centimetres. Each card links to one size and colour, so pick yours on the listing. For wide feet, the women's Newton Ridge Plus, Newton Ridge Plus 2 Suede, Crestwood and Moab 3 Mid GTX list US Wide sizes. Our merino socks guide compares socks to try boots on with.
Men's and women's listings
Buy from the listing made for your foot: the women's picks are the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped and the Merrell Moab 3 GTX, and the other five are men's. For footpaths rather than trails, our women's walking shoes guide compares walking shoes.
Frequently asked questions
Are hiking boots or hiking shoes better?
Neither suits everyone. A mid cut boot such as the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus or Merrell Moab 3 Mid GTX comes up around the ankle, and the Salomon listing says its higher cut wraps the ankle. A low cut shoe such as the Columbia Crestwood or Merrell Moab 3 leaves the ankle free.
What are the best hiking boots for women in Australia?
The Columbia Women's Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped: a mid cut, seam sealed leather and suede boot with an Omni Grip outsole and a reinforced toe and heel. For a low cut waterproof shoe, the Merrell Women's Moab 3 GTX pairs a GORE TEX membrane with a Vibram sole.
What are the best hiking boots for men?
The Columbia Newton Ridge Plus 2 Suede is the men's boot closest to the top pick. The Merrell Moab 3 Mid GTX adds GORE TEX and a Vibram sole, the Salomon X Ultra Pioneer Mid GTX suits climbs and descents, and the Columbia Crestwood is the low cut shoe.
Are hiking boots waterproof?
Not all of them. The Merrell Moab 3 Mid GTX, Moab 3 GTX and Salomon X Ultra Pioneer Mid GTX list GORE TEX membranes, and the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus 2 Suede an Omni Tech waterproof membrane bootie. The Merrell Moab 3 hiking shoe is marked not water resistant, and the Columbia Crestwood listing is mixed.
Which hiking boots are best for wide feet?
The Columbia Women's Newton Ridge Plus, Columbia Newton Ridge Plus 2 Suede and Merrell Moab 3 Mid GTX list US Wide sizes, and the Columbia Crestwood title says wide fit available. The Salomon and the women's Merrell Moab 3 GTX listings name no wide sizes.
How do I choose the right hiking boot size?
Use the size chart on the listing for the exact boot. The Merrell and Salomon charts give AU, UK, US and EU sizes, and the Columbia charts for the Crestwood and Newton Ridge Plus 2 give UK, US and EU sizes with heel to toe length in centimetres.
What is the best lightweight hiking shoe?
The Columbia Crestwood is the lightweight hiking shoe for men here: its title says high traction, lightweight and breathable. For women, the Merrell Moab 3 GTX spec table lists lightweight among its special features. The Salomon X Ultra Pioneer Mid GTX lists an item weight of 409 g, but its listing does not call it lightweight.
Can hiking boots be used as work boots?
Not as safety footwear. None of the seven listings here describes a steel or composite safety toe; the Merrell Moab 3 and Moab 3 GTX list a protective toe cap, a different claim. For a building site, choose a work boot instead.