The best school shoe overall is The Children's Place Girls Uniform Shoes Mary Jane Flat, a girls' uniform shoe with a 100% faux leather upper, a rubber outsole and a hook and loop closure at the front; for boys, the pick is the Deer Stags Gabe lace up. We compared six black school shoes for boys, girls and senior students on what their Amazon Australia listings state: style, closure, upper, US sizes and the star rating with its count.
The school year starts in late January or early February, depending on the state. Two picks are for girls, two for boys, one is a senior school shoe whose title says Kid's while its department line says girls', and one a unisex school sneaker. Sizes are the US sizes each listing gives, never Australian sizes, and no listing gives an age. Our running shoes guide covers adult road running shoes; this page is black shoes for the school uniform.
| Shoe | Listed for | Style and closure | Upper | Sizes listed |
| The Children's Place Mary Jane Flat | Girls | Mary Jane, hook and loop | 100% faux leather | 11 to 13 US Little Kid, 1 to 6 US Big Kid |
| Deer Stags Gabe | Boys | Lace up | Manmade leather (bullets), simulated leather (description), leather (spec table) | 5 US Toddler to 7 US Big Kid |
| Skechers Smooth Tracks Mary Jane | Girls | Mary Jane, buckle strap | Leather; one bullet says mesh and synthetic | 12 and 13 US Little Kid, 1 to 7 US Big Kid, 12.5 and 13.5 US Big Kid |
| Harrisons Daytona Senior School Shoe | Senior school (title); girls' (department line) | Lace up | Leather upper and lining | 5 to 14 US Big Kid, standard and wide |
| Apakowa Boys School Uniform Shoes | Boys | Lace up; the title says strap | Synthetic leather (bullets); leather (spec table) | 10 US Toddler, 11 to 3 US Little Kid, 4 to 6 US Big Kid |
| Fila Kids Graduate Shoe | Unisex kids | Sneaker, speed laces | Leather/synthetic (bullets, brand chart); faux leather (spec table) | 11 to 13 US Little Kid, 1 to 6 US Big Kid |
Best school shoe overall: The Children's Place Mary Jane Flat
Best school shoe overall: The Children's Place Girls Uniform Shoes Mary Jane Flat, because the listing pairs a 100% faux leather upper and a rubber outsole with a hook and loop closure, and it holds 4.6 stars from 1,981 ratings across versions.
The listing calls it a classic uniform shoe that keeps her comfortable all day long, made to pair with all her uniforms. The lining is twill and the spec table lists foam insole cushioning. Sizes listed are 11, 12 and 13 US Little Kid and 1 to 6 US Big Kid in black, and the care line reads machine wash. Its 4.6 stars are the highest of any pick here with more than 50 ratings.
It suits girls whose uniform calls for a black Mary Jane with a strap rather than laces. The honest catch: the title says Unisex-Child Girls and the department line says girls', and its sizes stop at 6 US Big Kid, so boys and senior students should read on.
Best lace up school shoe for boys: Deer Stags Gabe
Best lace up school shoe for boys: the Deer Stags Gabe Lace Up Dress Shoe, because the listing gives it a black upper (manmade leather in the bullets, simulated leather in the description, leather in the spec table), lace up entry for a custom fit and a durable rubber outsole, and its description names it for wear with a school uniform.
The Gabe is the most rated shoe on this page, with 4.3 stars from 4,142 ratings across versions. The spec table files it as an oxford with school uniform among its special features. Sizes run from 5 US Toddler to 7 US Big Kid in the boys' department, and the care line reads hand wash.
It suits boys whose uniform asks for a black lace up, from toddler sizes to 7 US Big Kid. The honest catch: the listing words the upper three ways (manmade leather in the bullets, simulated leather in the description, leather in the spec table), and its 4.3 stars sit below the Apakowa's 4.4.
Best buckle strap Mary Jane: Skechers Smooth Tracks Mary Jane
Best buckle strap Mary Jane: the Skechers Smooth Tracks Mary Jane Leather Shoe, because the description pairs a durable leather upper and a flexible rubber traction outsole with an Air Cooled Memory Foam insole, one bullet says mesh and synthetic upper, and the listing names it a school uniform shoe.
The spec table lists a buckle strap closure, a rubber sole and leather as the outer material. Sizes listed are 12 and 13 US Little Kid and 1 to 7 US Big Kid in Black/Black, plus 12.5 and 13.5 US Big Kid. It holds 4.8 stars from just 14 ratings.
It suits girls whose school asks for a black Mary Jane with a buckle strap. The honest catch: only 14 ratings so far, and one About this item bullet says mesh and synthetic upper while the model name, description and spec table say leather.
Best for senior school: Harrisons Daytona Senior School Shoe
Best for senior school: the Harrisons Kid's Daytona Senior School Shoe, because it has a leather upper and leather lining with lace closures, and the listing names sizes up to 14 US Big Kid in standard and wide versions.
The description calls it a school shoe with premium leather uppers, ideal for all day school wear. The listing adds padded collars and moulded internal heel counters, and the spec table lists a rubber sole and rates it water resistant. Sizes listed are 5 to 14 US Big Kid, each in standard and wide, the largest sizes on this page. It holds 4.3 stars from only 8 ratings.
It suits senior school students, the use its title names, and anyone who needs a wide fitting: it is the one pick here whose listing names wide sizes. The honest catch: only 8 ratings so far, and the title says Kid's while the department line says girls'.
Best boys dress shoe: Apakowa Boys School Uniform Shoes
Best boys dress shoe: the Apakowa Boys School Uniform Shoes, because this shoe, soft synthetic leather by its bullets and leather by its spec table, is listed from 10 US Toddler to 6 US Big Kid and the listing names school uniform among its uses.
The listing describes an upper of synthetic leather which is soft (the spec table's material row says leather), a synthetic sole durable for daily use and a lace up style for a customised fit, for party, wedding, church, school uniform and more. The item highlights also read breathable lining and non slip. Sizes listed are 10 US Toddler; 11, 12, 13, 1, 2 and 3 US Little Kid; and 4, 5 and 6 US Big Kid. It holds 4.4 stars from 374 ratings.
It suits boys from 10 US Toddler to 6 US Big Kid whose uniform asks for a black dress shoe. The honest catch: the title says adjustable strap while the closure line says lace up.
Best school sneaker: Fila Kids Graduate Shoe
Best school sneaker: the Fila Kids Graduate Shoe, because it pairs an upper the bullets call leather/synthetic and the spec table calls faux leather with a DLS foam midsole and a rubber sole, and the brand's comparison chart lists it as ideal for athletic and school wear.
The spec table calls it the Graduate Sneaker, a children's lace up shoe with speed laces. The listing adds a rubber sole for comfort and distance and synthetic overlays for lightweight, structured support. Sizes listed are 11, 12 and 13 US Little Kid and 1 to 6 US Big Kid in black, with a hand wash care line. It holds 4.3 stars from 43 ratings.
It suits boys and girls whose school allows a black sneaker, for the athletic and school wear the brand chart names. The honest catch: only 43 ratings so far, and not every uniform policy allows a sneaker.
How to choose school shoes
The school's uniform rules decide the style, so read them first. Every pick here is black. If the rules ask for leather, the Harrisons Daytona lists a leather upper and lining, and the Skechers Smooth Tracks names leather in its model name, description and spec table while one bullet says mesh and synthetic upper; if a black sneaker is allowed, the Fila Graduate is the one here.
Strap, buckle or laces
The listings name three closures, hook and loop, buckle strap and laces, and the Deer Stags listing says lace up entry gives a custom fit. The Children's Place Mary Jane Flat closes with hook and loop and the Skechers Smooth Tracks with a buckle strap. The Deer Stags Gabe and Harrisons Daytona use laces, and the Fila Graduate speed laces.
Read the US size labels, not an age
Every listing here uses US Toddler, Little Kid and Big Kid labels, and this page gives each size exactly as its listing gives it. For senior school, the Harrisons Daytona lists the biggest run, 5 to 14 US Big Kid, and it is the one pick listing wide sizes.
What the listings say about lasting
No listing gives a time a pair will last, so compare materials and rating counts. The Deer Stags Gabe lists a durable rubber outsole for lasting wear, the Harrisons Daytona durable outsoles, the Skechers description a durable leather upper though one Skechers bullet says mesh and synthetic upper, and the Apakowa a sole durable for daily use. The Deer Stags and The Children's Place carry the most ratings, at 4,142 and 1,981 ratings across versions.
The rest of the school kit
Shoes are one line on the back to school list. Our kids backpack guide compares school bags, and the back to school supplies guide covers the stationery list.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best school shoes for boys?
The Deer Stags Gabe: a black lace up with a durable rubber outsole and an upper listed as manmade, simulated and plain leather, from 5 US Toddler to 7 US Big Kid, with 4,142 ratings across versions. The Apakowa Boys School Uniform Shoes run 10 US Toddler to 6 US Big Kid; the Fila Graduate is the sneaker.
What are the best school shoes for girls?
The Children's Place Girls Uniform Shoes Mary Jane Flat: a faux leather Mary Jane with a hook and loop closure and a rubber outsole, from 11 US Little Kid to 6 US Big Kid. The Skechers Smooth Tracks Mary Jane has a buckle strap, a leather upper per its description, mesh and synthetic per one bullet, and only 14 ratings.
What are the best school shoes for high school?
The Harrisons Daytona Senior School Shoe: its title names it a senior school shoe, and the listing names sizes from 5 to 14 US Big Kid, each in standard and wide, with a leather upper, leather lining and lace closures. It has only 8 ratings so far.
What are the best school shoes for wide feet?
The Harrisons Daytona Senior School Shoe is the one pick on this page whose listing names wide sizes: every size from 5 to 14 US Big Kid is listed in a standard and a wide version. The other five listings name no wide fitting.
Do school shoes have to be black?
It depends on the school's uniform rules, so check them first. Every pick here is black: two Mary Janes for girls, lace ups from Deer Stags and Harrisons, the Apakowa Boys School Uniform Shoes, and the Fila Graduate school sneaker. If the rules ask for leather, the Harrisons Daytona lists a leather upper.
Do school shoes need to be leather?
Only if the uniform rules say so. The Harrisons Daytona lists a leather upper and lining, and The Children's Place Mary Jane Flat 100% faux leather. Four listings name more than one material in different blocks: Deer Stags Gabe manmade, simulated and plain leather; Fila Graduate leather/synthetic and faux leather; Apakowa synthetic leather and leather; Skechers leather and mesh.
School shoes or sneakers: which is better?
It depends on what the uniform allows. The Deer Stags Gabe and the Harrisons Daytona are black lace up school shoes. The Fila Graduate is a school sneaker: the brand chart lists it for athletic and school wear, with a DLS foam midsole and speed laces.
Can school shoes be washed in the washing machine?
Only one listing here says so: the care line for The Children's Place Mary Jane Flat reads machine wash. The Deer Stags Gabe and Fila Graduate listings say hand wash, and the Skechers, Harrisons and Apakowa listings give no care line.
What are the best school shoes for a kindergarten boy?
The Deer Stags Gabe, from 5 US Toddler, and the Apakowa Boys School Uniform Shoes, from 10 US Toddler, are the two picks with toddler sizes, though no listing on this page gives an age; the Apakowa title says strap while its closure line says lace up.