Choose the game first: ultimate practice, catching in the backyard, distance throwing or an evening game. These seven picks cover those uses, including one flying ring. Frisbee is a brand name that has become the everyday word for a flying disc, so the picks here come from several brands. Disc golf discs are outside this comparison. Every fact below comes from the listing itself, and each pick ends with its honest catch.
Best overall: Discraft Ultra Star
Best overall: the Discraft Ultra Star, because its listing calls it the world standard for ultimate and specifies a 175 g weight.
The listing describes the Ultra Star as the official and exclusive disc of the USA Ultimate Championship Series. Its product details give 175 g and one disc in the pack. It holds 4.8 stars from 23,637 ratings, the highest score and largest rating count among these seven picks.
It suits someone who wants the disc the listing calls the world standard for ultimate. The honest catch: the listing says the foil colour varies, so the pictured decoration is not a fixed choice. For a specifically soft catch design, consider the Funsparks instead.
Best for night games: Tosy LED Flying Disc
Best for night games: the Tosy LED Flying Disc, because its listing describes rechargeable lighting with motion sensors and adjustable brightness, timer, colour and style modes.
The feature bullets specify 108 RGB LEDs, 16.7 million colour variations and a 175 g disc. They describe automatic light switching and include one USB Type C to C cable. The disc holds 4.5 stars from 5,474 ratings.
It suits people whose evening throwing sessions make lighting worth choosing over a standard disc. The honest catch: it costs several times more than the Discraft, the details table calls the linked option the 36 LED version while the bullets describe 108 RGB LEDs, so check which version is selected, and the thousand throw claim is given for the B1 and T0 settings only. A charger is not included.
Best for distance (flying ring): Aerobie Pro Ring
Best for distance (flying ring): the Aerobie Pro Ring, because the listing describes a low profile design for long distance throws and soft edges for catching.
The Pro Ring has an open centre, a listed diameter of about 35.6 cm and a weight of about 145 g in the details table, which also gives a recommended age of 12 years and up. The listing says it was used for a Guinness World Record throw of 406 m; that is a record claim, not a promised distance for your own throw. It holds 4.6 stars from 8,067 ratings.
It suits people who want distance throwing as the game itself. The honest catch: it is a ring, so choose the Discraft or Duncan if your aim is an ultimate disc. The listing also says the colour may vary.
Best for the beach and pool: Aerobie Superdisc
Best for the beach and pool: the Aerobie Superdisc, because the listing says it floats on water and has a cushioned edge for softer catches.
The listing describes a thin, low profile design with a spoiler rim, a diameter of about 25.4 cm, a weight of about 186 g in the details table, and use by novices and veteran throwers. It holds 4.6 stars from 841 ratings. For more games around the water, see our pool toys guide.
It suits beach and pool days where a floating disc is the deciding feature. The honest catch: the pack contains one disc in one of four colours, rather than all four pictured colours, and you do not choose which one.
Best soft catch disc: Funsparks Easy Disk
Best soft catch disc: the Funsparks Easy Disk, because the listing describes a soft disc with an outer ring that bends.
The bullets say it floats, give a diameter of about 24.1 cm and describe it as for players of all ages and skill levels and perfect for 6 year olds and up. They claim flights up to about 33.5 m. It holds 4.5 stars from 130 ratings.
It suits beginners who want a soft disc for learning to catch. The honest catch: there are only 130 ratings so far, and the listing disagrees with itself on weight: 136 g in the bullets versus 150 g in the product details. Choose it for the soft construction, rather than a precise weight requirement.
Best for young kids: Nerf Sonic Slinger
Best for young kids: the Nerf Sonic Slinger, because its listing describes a lightweight disc with a soft outer edge and four whistles that howl in flight.
The listing gives a diameter of about 27.9 cm, describes indoor and outdoor play, and says the lightweight design helps smaller hands catch and toss it. It holds 4.0 stars from 62 ratings. The whistles make sound part of the throwing game.
It suits kids who want a disc that howls when thrown. The honest catch: only 62 ratings support its score, the lowest average on this page. The listing gives no numerical age range.
Best alternative sport disc: Duncan Sky Rider Ultimate
Best alternative sport disc: the Duncan Sky Rider Ultimate, because the listing describes a 175 g USA Ultimate approved disc with a smooth glide.
The title names Sky Rider Ultimate, while the feature bullets call the disc Intrepid 175G. Those bullets describe competitive use and backyard throwing, and specify one disc. The details table gives an age range from 96 months, which is 8 years, and a 30 day warranty against manufacturer defects. It holds 4.7 stars from 1,188 ratings.
It suits an ultimate player who wants to compare another brand with the Discraft. The honest catch: the colour may vary, and the listing uses two model names. Check that the selected option matches the 175 g disc described here. Its rating count is much smaller than the Ultra Star's.
How to choose a frisbee
Compare the listed specifications
Start with weight, size and the feature you will use. A missing specification is shown as not stated; it does not mean the product lacks that feature. Dimensions below follow the listing's stated unit conversions, with the Funsparks weight discrepancy kept visible.
Frisbee listing specifications compared| Pick | Weight | Listing size | Key listing feature |
|---|
| Discraft Ultra Star | 175 g | 27.5 by 27.5 by 4 cm | Ultimate Championship Series disc |
|---|
| Tosy LED Flying Disc | 175 g | 27 by 27 by 3.7 cm | 108 RGB LEDs, rechargeable |
|---|
| Aerobie Pro Ring | about 145 g in details | About 35.6 cm diameter | Open centre, soft edges |
|---|
| Aerobie Superdisc | about 186 g in details | About 25.4 cm diameter | Floats, cushioned edge |
|---|
| Funsparks Easy Disk | 136 g in bullets; 150 g in details | About 24.1 cm diameter | Soft disc, floats |
|---|
| Nerf Sonic Slinger | not stated | About 27.9 cm diameter | Soft outer edge, four whistles |
|---|
| Duncan Sky Rider Ultimate | 175 g | not stated | USA Ultimate approved |
|---|
Which disc for ultimate frisbee
Discraft calls its 175 g Ultra Star the world standard for ultimate. Duncan lists USA Ultimate approval, while Tosy says its 175 g disc meets Professional Ultimate standards. Those are three different wordings, so match the claim to what your league or club asks for. Nerf's statement that its disc is approximately ultimate size does not give it a stated 175 g weight.
Separate a soft edge from a soft disc
Aerobie Superdisc has a cushioned edge; the Pro Ring and Nerf Sonic Slinger describe soft edges. Funsparks describes a soft disc with a bendable outer ring. That distinction helps when choosing for catching practice. The Funsparks bullets say all ages and skill levels and perfect for 6 year olds and up, the Pro Ring details table says 12 years and up, and Nerf gives no numerical age range.
Match floating play or distance throwing
The Superdisc and Easy Disk listings explicitly say they float. The Pro Ring instead emphasises distance and an open centre. Choose the feature that matches your plans rather than assuming every flying disc does both. For another game to share the afternoon, our cricket set guide covers backyard and beach options.
Decide whether lights or sound add to the game
Tosy provides adjustable LED modes and motion sensor switching; Nerf adds four whistles. Those are different reasons to choose a disc. For Tosy, the included cable and excluded charger matter alongside its lighting modes. The thousand throw figure is given for the B1 and T0 settings only.
Compare the exact disc and the rating count
The Ultra Star's 23,637 ratings give a different amount of feedback from Nerf's 62. Read the model details too: Duncan uses Sky Rider and Intrepid names, while Aerobie Superdisc specifies one disc despite showing several colours.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best frisbee in Australia?
The Discraft Ultra Star is our pick for most people. Its listing specifies 175 g and calls it the world standard for ultimate. Choose the Aerobie Superdisc for a floating disc with a cushioned edge, or the Tosy LED Flying Disc if lighting is the feature you want.
What is the best frisbee for beginners?
For learning to catch, choose the Funsparks Easy Disk: its listing describes a soft disc with a bendable outer ring. For learning ultimate, choose the Discraft Ultra Star with its listed 175 g weight. The Aerobie Superdisc is another option, with a cushioned edge and a listing that names novices.
What weight disc should I choose for ultimate frisbee?
The Discraft Ultra Star listing calls its 175 g disc the world standard for ultimate. Duncan Sky Rider Ultimate also lists 175 g and says it is USA Ultimate approved. Tosy lists the same weight and claims Professional Ultimate standards, but that is different wording from Duncan's approval claim.
Which Aerobie frisbee is best for me?
Choose the Aerobie Pro Ring for distance throwing with an open centre and soft edges. Choose the Aerobie Superdisc for a round disc with a cushioned edge that the listing says floats. The ring is about 35.6 cm across; the Superdisc is about 25.4 cm across.
What is the best frisbee for kids?
The Nerf Sonic Slinger is our kids pick because its listing describes a lightweight body, a soft outer edge and four whistles that howl during flight. It gives no numerical age range. The Funsparks Easy Disk bullets say all ages and skill levels, and call it perfect for 6 year olds and up.
Which is the best dog frisbee among these picks?
The Aerobie Superdisc is the closest match here: its listing describes a soft edge and mentions use by dog disc entertainers. The Funsparks Easy Disk listing also mentions play with dogs. These are options within our throwing disc comparison, rather than a separate ranking of specialist dog frisbees.
What do buyer reviews say about these frisbees?
The Discraft Ultra Star holds 4.8 stars from 23,637 ratings, the highest score and the largest count here. The Aerobie Pro Ring has 4.6 from 8,067, the Tosy 4.5 from 5,474 and the Duncan 4.7 from 1,188. The Funsparks Easy Disk and Nerf Sonic Slinger have 130 and 62 ratings, so treat their scores as early.
Which frisbee brands should I compare in Australia?
Start with the type you want: Discraft Ultra Star or Duncan Sky Rider Ultimate for ultimate, Aerobie Superdisc for floating play, and Funsparks Easy Disk or Nerf Sonic Slinger for soft catch features. Tosy adds lighting. Compare the exact model and variant rather than choosing by brand name alone.
Is a rechargeable LED frisbee worth it for night games?
The Tosy LED Flying Disc suits people who want adjustable lighting and motion sensor switching. Its listing describes 108 RGB LEDs and a 30 minute charge, with up to a thousand throws specifically at B1 and T0 settings. A USB Type C to C cable is included, but a charger is not.
