The best primer for most people is the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer, because the listing calls it a gel based face primer that grips makeup, goes on clear for all skin types and skin tones, and holds hyaluronic acid to retain moisture. This page compares seven face primers from five brands by what each listing and its spec table state, plus the star rating and rating count, covering gripping, blurring, matte, hydrating, smoothing and illuminating formulas.
Every listing words its claims differently, so each section quotes the listing and names the block when two blocks of one listing disagree. Eye shadow primers, eyelash primers and setting sprays are different products and are left out. Our best foundation guide compares the foundations themselves, whereas this page compares the primers the listings say to apply before makeup.
The seven primers side by side
Only what each listing or its spec table states; a cell says not stated where the listing gives nothing.
| Primer | Size (listing) | Finish words (listing) | Skin type words (listing) | Wear time (listing) |
| e.l.f. Power Grip Primer | 24 ml (title) | Natural and translucent (bullets); satin and dewy (spec table) | All skin types and skin tones | No hour figure stated |
| Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer | 1 count (title); the spec table volume rows disagree | Fresh, plumped skin look (bullets); natural (spec table) | All skin types | Up to 24H (title and bullets) |
| L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Face Blurring Primer | 30 ml (spec table; title gives no size) | Natural looking soft focus (bullets); radiant (spec table) | Mature skin (product description); All (spec table) | No hour figure stated |
| L'Oreal Paris Prime Lab 24 Hour Matte Primer | 30 ml (title) | Matte (bullets and spec table) | Oily (spec table); bullets name none | 24 Hour (title) |
| NYX Plump Right Back Primer | 30 ml (title) | Hydrated and plump (bullets); dewy (spec table) | All skin types | No hour figure in the bullets; product description says all day makeup extension |
| NYX The Marsh Mellow Primer | 30 ml (title) | Transparent and soft focus (title and bullets); sheer (spec table) | All skin types | Up to 16 hours (bullets) |
| Natio Ageless Illuminating Primer | 50 g (title) | Radiant base (bullets); satin (spec table) | All skin types | No hour figure stated; bullets say longer wearing makeup |
Best face primer overall: e.l.f. Power Grip Primer
Best face primer overall: the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer, because the listing calls it a gel based face primer that grips makeup, goes on clear for all skin types and skin tones, and holds hyaluronic acid to retain moisture.
The e.l.f. Power Grip Primer listing describes a gel based, hydrating face primer in a 24 ml size that smoothes skin while gripping makeup. The bullets say the formula goes on clear with a translucent finish, is non comedogenic (the listing explains this as does not clog pores) and is infused with hyaluronic acid to retain moisture for a plump complexion, and the listing says all e.l.f. products are 100% cruelty free and vegan. Its directions say to apply evenly to the face before makeup and to wait 30 seconds before applying makeup. It holds 4.6 stars from 41,926 ratings, the most ratings of any primer on this page.
It suits someone who wants a primer before makeup, the use its listing names, across all skin types and skin tones as the listing words it. The honest catch: the finish words differ by block, with natural and translucent in the bullets, a soft focus effect in the product description and satin and dewy in the spec table, and the listing never calls it a matte primer.
Best grippy serum primer with 2% niacinamide: Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer
Best grippy serum primer with 2% niacinamide: the Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer, because the listing calls it a hydrating makeup primer with 2% niacinamide for up to 24HR make up wear that gives a fresh, plumped skin look.
The listing describes a water based serum primer formulated with 2 percent niacinamide. Its bullets say the serum texture transforms to a sticky feel after 20 seconds that grips makeup for up to 24H, that it gives 24H hydration, layers well with makeup and does not pill, and that there is no white cast or greasy feel. It is listed as a non comedogenic, vegan formula for all skin types, and the spec table lists the item form as serum. Its directions say to apply evenly with the dropper, pat in with fingertips and allow 20 seconds before applying makeup. It holds 4.6 stars from 3,081 ratings.
It suits someone who wants a primer before makeup, the use its listing names. The honest catch: its title gives 1 count while its spec table volume rows disagree with each other, its finish is natural in the spec table but a fresh, plumped skin look in the bullets, and its 3,081 ratings are far fewer than the 41,926 on the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer.
Best blurring primer for mature skin: L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Face Blurring Primer
Best blurring primer for mature skin: the L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Face Blurring Primer, because the product description calls it makeup specially designed for mature skin and the listing says it instantly smooths the look of lines and pores with a soft focus finish.
The bullets describe a blurring face primer infused with a caring serum, with a universal rosy formula, that can be worn alone or with Age Perfect radiant serum foundation or creamy powder foundation. They say it instantly smooths the look of lines and pores and diffuses the look of lines with a natural looking, soft focus finish. The product description block calls it makeup specially designed for mature skin and says skin feels comfortable all day long, while the spec table lists skin type as All, finish as radiant, specialty as pore smoothing and a volume of 30 ml. Its directions say it can be worn alone or under makeup. It holds 4.3 stars from 15,078 ratings.
It suits someone who wants a primer worn alone, under makeup or with the Age Perfect foundations, the uses its listing names. The honest catch: the formula is rosy rather than clear, its bullets say a natural looking, soft focus finish while its spec table says radiant, and its 4.3 stars sit below the 4.6 on the e.l.f. and Maybelline listings.
Best matte primer: L'Oreal Paris Prime Lab 24 Hour Matte Primer
Best matte primer: the L'Oreal Paris Prime Lab 24 Hour Matte Primer, because the listing says it reduces shine, grips makeup and leaves a matte finish as a matte makeup base.
The title calls it a 24 Hour Matte Primer, and the five short bullets read Grips makeup, Reduces shine, Rebalance skin overtime, Matte finish and Matte makeup base. The product description block says it is concentrated with perlite to mattify and absorb oil, and the maker's section names it the 24H Matte Setter. The spec table lists an oil control benefit, a lotion form, a matte finish and mattifying coverage. Its title gives a size of 30 ml. It holds 4.4 stars from 1,400 ratings.
It suits someone who wants a matte base, the use its bullets name, and its directions say it can be used alone or under makeup. The honest catch: the listing is short, its bullets name no skin type while its spec table names oily skin, and its 1,400 ratings are far fewer than the 41,926 on the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer or the 15,078 on the Age Perfect primer.
Best hydrating and plumping primer: NYX Plump Right Back Primer
Best hydrating and plumping primer: the NYX Plump Right Back Primer, because the listing calls it a lightweight serum based primer for all skin types with hyaluronic acid and vitamin E that gives skin a hydrated and plump finish.
The bullets describe a serum based primer for all skin types that leaves skin feeling smooth and helps with even makeup application, in a lightweight vegan formula enriched with hyaluronic acid, vitamin E, pro vitamin B5, magnesium and potassium, in a 30 ml size. They say to apply a dime sized amount using an applicator or your fingers. The spec table lists a gel form, a plumping specialty and a dewy finish. It holds 4.5 stars from 5,293 ratings.
It suits someone who wants smoother skin and even makeup application, the uses its bullets name. The honest catch: its bullets make no grip or wear time claim, and only the product description block mentions all day makeup extension, so it reads as a skin feel primer more than a hold primer, and its finish is hydrated and plump in the bullets but dewy in the spec table.
Best smoothing primer: NYX The Marsh Mellow Primer
Best smoothing primer: the NYX The Marsh Mellow Primer, because the listing says it hydrates and smoothens skin for a soft focus, transparent finish on all skin types and helps makeup stay on for up to 16 hours.
The title calls it a smoothing and evening primer with a transparent finish for all skin types, in a 30 ml size. The bullets say it hydrates and smoothens skin for a soft focus finish and helps makeup stay on for up to 16 hours, in a vegan formula infused with smoothing marshmallow root extract, applied as a pea sized amount with fingers, a brush or the Marshmellow Blender Sponge before foundation; the contents line lists one primer only. The spec table lists a cream form and a sheer finish, with a coverage row that says minimises pores, fine lines and uneven skin tone. It holds 4.4 stars from 11,021 ratings.
It suits someone who wants a primer before foundation, the use its bullets name. The honest catch: the listing states wear of up to 16 hours, against up to 24H in the Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer listing, and its soft focus finish is a smoothing effect rather than a matte one, with the spec table finish saying sheer.
Best illuminating primer: Natio Ageless Illuminating Primer
Best illuminating primer: the Natio Ageless Illuminating Primer, because the listing calls it a radiance boosting primer made in Australia with rosehip oil, vitamin C and shea butter for a smooth, radiant base on all skin types.
The title gives a 50 g size and says made in Australia, and the detail rows list Australia as the country of origin. The bullets describe organic rosehip oil, vitamin C, aloe vera, sesame and shea butter to hydrate, as a smooth, radiant base for flawless and longer wearing makeup application, suitable for all skin types, with key naturals of rosehip, aloe vera, sesame, shea, lemon, lavender, ylang ylang, geranium and rose. The spec table lists a cream form in a tube and a satin finish. The listing says to glide a pea sized amount over clean skin and to follow with your favourite Natio foundation. It holds 4.6 stars from 127 ratings.
It suits someone who wants a base before foundation, the use its listing names, including the Natio foundation it mentions. The honest catch: it has only 127 ratings, its key naturals include lemon, lavender, ylang ylang, geranium and rose, and its finish is a radiant base in the bullets but satin in the spec table.
How to choose a primer
The listings describe six jobs
The seven listings group into six jobs: grip (e.l.f. Power Grip Primer and Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer), blurring (L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect), matte (L'Oreal Paris Prime Lab), hydrating and plumping (NYX Plump Right Back), smoothing (NYX The Marsh Mellow Primer) and illuminating (Natio Ageless Illuminating Primer). The e.l.f. and Maybelline listings also describe hydration, with hyaluronic acid named on the e.l.f. listing and 2% niacinamide on the Maybelline listing, so grip and hydration are not separate lists. The Prime Lab matte listing also says Grips makeup in its bullets.
Skin type words in the listings
Six of the seven listings say all skin types, in their text or their spec table, and no listing names dry or combination skin in its product text. The Age Perfect product description names mature skin and the Prime Lab spec table names oily skin. The Prime Lab maker's section says to apply primer after the morning skincare routine and before foundation and concealer, and our best moisturiser guide covers the skincare step.
Finish words and why blocks disagree
A primer's finish word depends on which block of the listing is read, so the table above names the block each time. The e.l.f. listing gives natural, translucent, soft focus and satin and dewy in three blocks, the Natio listing a radiant base in the bullets and satin in the spec table, and the NYX Plump Right Back listing hydrated and plump in the bullets and dewy in the spec table. The Prime Lab bullets and spec table both say matte.
Wear time claims
The listings give wear times in different forms, and each is the maker's claim. The Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer states up to 24H, the Prime Lab title says 24 Hour, and the NYX The Marsh Mellow Primer says up to 16 hours. The e.l.f., Age Perfect and Natio listings give no hour figure, and the NYX Plump Right Back product description says all day makeup extension.
Face primers only
This page compares face primers; eye shadow primers, eyelash primers, paint primers and setting sprays are different products. Setting sprays have their own page, our best setting spray guide, and none is on this list.
Rating counts differ a lot
Three listings hold 4.6 stars, the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer, the Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer and the Natio Ageless Illuminating Primer, on counts of 41,926, 3,081 and 127, so the same star figure rests on very different amounts of feedback.
Frequently asked questions
Which is the best face primer?
The e.l.f. Power Grip Primer is the best face primer on this page: the listing calls it a gel based, hydrating face primer that grips makeup, goes on clear for all skin types and skin tones, and holds hyaluronic acid. It is also the most rated, and the Maybelline and Prime Lab listings also say they grip makeup.
What is the best primer for mature skin in Australia?
The L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Face Blurring Primer: its product description calls it makeup specially designed for mature skin, and its bullets say it instantly smooths the look of lines and pores with a soft focus finish. Its spec table lists skin type as All, and no other listing here names mature skin.
What is the best primer for oily skin?
The L'Oreal Paris Prime Lab 24 Hour Matte Primer: its spec table names oily skin and a matte finish, and its bullets say it grips makeup and reduces shine. Its bullets name no skin type, and it has 1,400 ratings, far fewer than the 41,926 on the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer.
Which primer makes makeup last longer?
The Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer states up to 24H of makeup wear in its title and bullets, and the Prime Lab Matte Primer says 24 Hour in its title. The NYX The Marsh Mellow Primer says makeup stays on for up to 16 hours, while the e.l.f. Power Grip listing says it grips makeup without giving a time.
Which primer is best for glowing skin?
The Natio Ageless Illuminating Primer is the illuminating pick: its listing calls it a radiance boosting primer that creates a smooth, radiant base for makeup. The L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect primer has a rosy formula and a radiant finish in its spec table, while the Natio spec table lists a satin finish.
Which primer blurs pores?
The L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Face Blurring Primer: its bullets say it instantly smooths the look of lines and pores, and its spec table lists pore smoothing and blurring coverage. The NYX The Marsh Mellow Primer spec table has a coverage row that says minimises pores, fine lines and uneven skin tone.
Which company has the best primer?
On these listings e.l.f. has the most rated primer, the Power Grip at 4.6 stars from 41,926 ratings. Maybelline and Natio also hold 4.6 stars, on 3,081 and 127 ratings, NYX holds 4.5 and 4.4 on its two primers, and L'Oreal Paris holds 4.3 and 4.4. These are shoppers' scores, not tests.
Is there a primer for dry or combination skin?
No listing here names dry or combination skin in its product text. Six of the seven list all skin types, including the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer, the Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer and the NYX Plump Right Back Primer, which gives a hydrated and plump finish, while the Prime Lab spec table names oily skin.