The best tubing mascara for most people is the L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes, because its listing describes a two step formula whose tube top coat sets into lash extending tubes on a mascara the listing says stays on all day. This page compared six tubing mascaras from six brands using only what each listing, its directions and its spec table state, and every one says tubing or tube in its own listing.
Our best mascara guide covers mascara in general; this page keeps to listings that name a tubing or tube formula. The table sets the six listings side by side before the picks.
| Mascara | Tubing words in the listing | Size | How the listing says it comes off | Brush or wand |
| L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes | Beauty Tubes; Tubing Technology | About 9.8 ml | Warm water; also soap and water (product description) | Standard wand type (spec table) |
| tarte tartelette XL tubing mascara | Tubing XL peptide blend; removes in tubes | About 8 ml | Just warm water | Curved wand (spec table); 360 degree lash extension comb |
| Hourglass Unlocked Instant Extension Mascara | Tubing mascara; tubing technology | 10 ml | Splash warm water, slide the tubes off with fingers (directions) | Moulded brush |
| SHEGLAM All In One Primer and Tubing Volume Mascara | Tubing mascara; tubes slide off | No volume stated; 13.5 by 2.2 by 2.2 cm, 20 g | Warm water removal (bullets) | Not stated |
| Revolution Wrap Lash Tubing Mascara | Tubing mascara; tubing technology | 8.5 ml | Just warm water, wet fingers pressed onto the lashes | Maxi V brush, V shaped wand |
| Natio Infinite Tubing Mascara | Tubing mascara formulation | 7 ml each, pack of 2 | Cotton pad soaked in warm water held on the lashes for 30 seconds | Large domed brush |
Best tubing mascara overall: L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes
Best tubing mascara overall: the L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes, because the listing describes a two step formula, a base coat then a tube top coat that sets into lash extending tubes, on a mascara it says stays on all day.
The title calls it Double Extend Beauty Tubes Lengthening Mascara in Blackest Black, and the bullets name 2 Step Length Tubing Technology and an Extension Effect. The product description says the first step is a base coat and the second is the Ultra Lengthening Tube Top Coat that sets to form lash extending beauty tubes, with up to 80% longer looking lashes. It calls the mascara run free, smudge free, clump free and flake free, and says that while it stays on all day it is easily removable with just warm water, with no makeup remover or rubbing required; the same description also says it is easily removable with soap and water. The directions say to apply step 1, then immediately step 2 with no drying time between. The volume is about 9.8 ml. It holds 4.4 stars from 17,103 ratings across versions.
It suits someone who wants the lengthening the listing describes from a two coat system. The honest catch: it is a two step mascara, a base coat then the tube top coat, and its rating count is shared across versions of the listing.
Best tubing mascara with a curved wand and lash comb: tarte tartelette XL
Best tubing mascara with a curved wand and lash comb: the tarte tartelette XL tubing mascara, because the listing pairs a tubing XL peptide blend for length, lift and pigment with a 360 degree lash extension comb and says it removes in tubes with just warm water.
The linked listing is the black full size. The bullets describe a tubing XL peptide blend for XL length, XL lift and XL pigment, a 360 degree lash extension comb for full on flutter, and a creamy, buildable formula for a lash extension effect. The product description says it creates a lash extension effect and removes in tubes with just warm water in secs, and the directions repeat that it removes in tubes with just warm water. The spec table gives a curved wand and about 8 ml. It holds 4.4 stars from 5,613 ratings across versions, shared with its Brown and Travel Size versions.
It suits a reader who wants the curved wand, the 360 degree lash extension comb and a lash extension effect, the use its listing names. The honest catch: the 24 hour, smudge proof wear claim rests on a clinical study of 33 subjects that the listing cites.
Best tubing mascara for lifted, fanned out lashes: Hourglass Unlocked Instant Extension Mascara
Best tubing mascara for lifted, fanned out lashes: the Hourglass Unlocked Instant Extension Mascara, because the title says it lifts, defines and lengthens for fanned out lashes with up to 16 hours of smudge proof, flake free wear, and the bullets say its moulded brush coats each lash for separation, volume and lift.
The title calls it a tubing mascara that dramatically lifts, defines and lengthens for fanned out lashes. The bullets describe a moulded brush that grabs and coats each lash for precise separation, volume and lift, perfect for natural or bold eye makeup looks, and tubing technology that wraps each lash in lightweight polymers to prevent flaking and fallout. The product description words that differently: film forming technology that coats each lash in lightweight fibres for a fanned out finish. The directions add that a lash curler before mascara gives a more dramatic lengthening effect. The spec table gives 10 ml and a gel item form. It holds 4.3 stars from 1,278 ratings.
It suits someone after the natural or bold looks the listing names. The honest catch: it has fewer ratings than the top two picks, and its title and bullets name no shade, though the spec table colour row says Black.
Best primer and tubing mascara for buildable volume: SHEGLAM All In One Primer and Tubing Volume Mascara
Best primer and tubing mascara for buildable volume: the SHEGLAM All In One Primer and Tubing Volume Mascara, because the listing pairs a conditioning white primer with a weightless tubing formula that it says builds volume and slides off with warm water.
The linked listing is the Tubing Black colour. The bullets describe a dual ended lash system of primer plus tubing mascara, a conditioning white primer that preps, smooths and boosts fullness for a better mascara base, weightless tubing volume that wraps each lash for length, definition and buildable volume, and easy warm water removal where tubes slide off clean with no smudging and no tugging. The listing states product dimensions of 13.5 by 2.2 by 2.2 cm and a weight of 20 g, and gives no volume. It holds 4.2 stars from 1,926 ratings.
It suits a reader who wants a primer and a tubing mascara in one product, the pairing the listing names. The honest catch: the listing gives no wear time, it has fewer ratings than the top picks, and its count sits on a listing with six colour versions.
Best burgundy tubing mascara: Revolution Wrap Lash Tubing Mascara in Burgundy
Best burgundy tubing mascara: the Revolution Wrap Lash Tubing Mascara in Burgundy, because the listing pairs a tubing formula with a Maxi V brush for length, lift and volume and says it slides off with just warm water.
The title calls it Wrap Lash Tubing Mascara in Burgundy. The bullets call it an innovative tubing mascara with mega length, lift and volume and 24 hour wear that stays flake free and budge proof all day, and the description cites a blind trial on 115 users for 24 hours. The 3 in 1 Maxi V brush has a V shaped wand, and the bullets say no makeup remover or micellar water is needed, just warm water pressed on with wet fingers. The description's top tip says the formula can feel tacky until it dries. The spec table gives 8.5 ml. It holds 4.2 stars from 1,105 ratings.
It suits a reader who wants a coloured tubing mascara; the listing names black, burgundy and brown shades. The honest catch: Burgundy is a colour rather than a classic black, and the Wrap Lash listing names other shades.
Best tubing mascara with a large domed brush: Natio Infinite Tubing Mascara
Best tubing mascara with a large domed brush: the Natio Infinite Tubing Mascara, because the listing says its large domed brush builds length and volume coat by coat and the tubing formula wears all day without clumps, flakes or smudges, then lifts off with warm water.
The linked listing is Black, 7 ml, in a pack of 2, and its bullets say the information is per pack. The title calls it Infinite Tubing Mascara, and the bullets describe a new generation tubing mascara formulation with a large domed brush designed to build length and volume. The listing says one coat gives a subtle look and additional coats give more amplified volume, length and separation. For removal it says tubing mascara requires no makeup remover: saturate a cotton pad with warm water and hold it against the lashes for 30 seconds, then gently wipe. The spec table gives 14 ml across the 2 tubes. It holds 4.4 stars from 90 ratings.
It suits a reader who wants a dome brush and the subtle to amplified looks the listing names. The honest catch: it has only 90 ratings, and the listing is a pack of 2.
How to choose a tubing mascara
What tubing mascara means in these listings
A tubing mascara is a formula its listing says wraps each lash and comes off in tubes with warm water. The Hourglass bullets describe tubing technology that wraps each lash in lightweight polymers (its product description says lightweight fibres), the tarte listing says it removes in tubes, the SHEGLAM bullets say tubes slide off clean, and the L'Oréal description says its top coat sets to form lash extending beauty tubes.
How each listing says it comes off
All six listings give a warm water removal step, but the steps differ. L'Oréal says just warm water in one sentence and soap and water in another, Hourglass says splash warm water and slide the tubes off with fingers, Revolution says press wet fingers onto the lashes, and Natio says hold a cotton pad soaked in warm water on the lashes for 30 seconds. Some of the spec tables carry a water rating row that sits against the listing's own warm water removal words; this page leaves that row out and goes by the removal words.
One step, two steps or a primer
The L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes is the two step choice: a base coat, then the tube top coat. The SHEGLAM listing pairs a conditioning white primer with its tubing mascara in a dual ended system. The tarte, Hourglass, Revolution and Natio listings describe a single mascara formula.
Brush and wand shape
The listings name four different brush shapes. Tarte gives a 360 degree lash extension comb and curved wand, Hourglass a moulded brush, Revolution a Maxi V brush with a V shaped wand, and Natio a large domed brush. The L'Oréal spec table gives a standard wand type, and the SHEGLAM listing states no wand shape. The Hourglass directions add that a lash curler before mascara gives a more dramatic lengthening effect; our eyelash curler guide compares manual curlers.
Colour and size
Five of the six cards link a black shade, and Revolution is the one coloured pick, in Burgundy. Stated sizes run from 7 ml for each Natio tube to 10 ml for the Hourglass, and the SHEGLAM listing gives no volume.
Wear claims are the makers' words
Each wear claim here is the listing's own wording. Hourglass says up to 16 hours in its title, tarte says 24 hour longwear and cites a study of 33 subjects, Revolution says 24 hour wear and cites a trial of 115 users, and L'Oréal and Natio say it stays on or wears all day. The SHEGLAM listing gives no wear time. When a pick finishes a look, our brow gel guide covers the brows.
Ratings and rating counts
Star ratings run from 4.2 to 4.4 across the six, so the counts matter more. The L'Oréal and tarte counts are shared across versions of each listing, the SHEGLAM count sits on a listing with six colour versions, the Revolution listing names three shades, and the Natio count of 90 is for a pack of 2.
Frequently asked questions
Which one is tubing mascara?
Tubing mascara is a formula whose listing says it wraps each lash and comes off with warm water. All six picks here say tubing or tube in their own listings, from the L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes to the Natio Infinite Tubing Mascara, and the removal steps are not all the same.
What is the best tubing mascara in Australia?
The L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes is the best tubing mascara for most people here. Its listing describes a two step formula, a base coat then a tube top coat that sets into lash extending tubes, and says it stays on all day. It carries the highest rating count on this page.
How do you remove tubing mascara?
The Hourglass Unlocked directions say to splash warm water onto the eyes and slide the mascara tubes off with fingers. Revolution says press wet fingers onto the lashes, Natio says hold a cotton pad soaked in warm water on the lashes for 30 seconds, and tarte says it removes in tubes with just warm water.
How do you get a natural mascara look with tubing mascara?
The Natio Infinite Tubing Mascara listing says to apply one coat for a subtle look and additional coats for more amplified volume, length and separation. The Hourglass Unlocked listing calls its moulded brush perfect for natural or bold eye makeup looks, and the tarte listing calls its formula creamy and buildable.
What is the best brown tubing mascara in Australia?
None of the six cards here is brown, but the tarte tartelette XL listing names Black and Brown colours and the Revolution Wrap Lash listing names black, burgundy and brown shades. The tarte card links the black full size and the Revolution card links Burgundy, so brown is a separate colour option on each listing.
Which tubing mascara comes in two steps or with a primer?
The L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes is a two step system: its directions say to apply step 1, then immediately step 2. The SHEGLAM All In One Primer and Tubing Volume Mascara is a dual ended system pairing a conditioning white primer with a tubing mascara. The other four are single formulas.
Which tubing mascara gives a lash extension look?
Three listings use lash extension words. The L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes lists an Extension Effect, the Hourglass Unlocked promises the dramatic, lifted look of lash extensions, and the tarte tartelette XL says it creates a lash extension effect. These are the makers' listing claims, not results this page measured.
Which tubing mascara has the most ratings?
The L'Oréal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes shows 17,103 ratings across versions, and the tarte tartelette XL shows 5,613 across versions. The SHEGLAM has 1,926 on a listing with six colours, the Hourglass 1,278, the Revolution 1,105 and the Natio only 90, on a pack of 2.